ABOGADO SINABING UNETHICAL AT PAMBABASTOS ANG SINABI NI VP SARA DUTERTE
00:35.0
before that mga kabatas natin eh Tignan
00:38.7
natin no yung isang reaksyon din ng
00:42.9
abogado Who was a former IBP President
00:46.8
doon sa ginawa nitong si VP saro Duterte
00:51.6
mali hindi nagpapakumbaba
00:58.0
nag-iisip para daw yan Okay ba yung
01:01.0
audio natin mga kapos natin so we can
01:02.7
start hirap pero puro yaman at L mo alam
01:08.0
pinagkakakitaan ka
01:11.6
nito parami rin siya ng manloloko hing
01:15.9
at magaganda ang mga pelikula nito
01:18.2
Kakantahan ka at aaliwin ng tuluyan para
01:22.0
sa bota mo siya ang number one ipakitang
01:25.4
Gilas okay ba okay ba babango sa harap
01:29.0
ng cera dala mo santo pero sa likod
01:32.4
Grabe ang likod sa sariling multo lang
01:35.0
it mo takot halang ang hinahalal h puso
01:38.1
ang wanal Asal Asal may alik may
01:42.0
kriminal mga taong walang moral moral
01:46.0
ganyan kami migil lang magigiting na
01:48.9
kawal hasting na babaero o at mangloloko
01:51.9
dapat panay ang biso at Masama kang tao
01:54.6
kung h halamang bituka mo di ka iboboto
01:58.2
pilipino okay let's go mga kabatas natin
02:02.4
bago tayo tumungo diyan no sa ano doon
02:07.2
yon well bago nating pag-aralan totally
02:10.3
mga kabatas natin let me Remind You
02:12.7
Again of what happened Okay This is what
02:15.4
happened and this is this is Uh the very
02:19.0
clip din na nrea ng isang dating IBP
02:23.3
Okay sa security ko kasi may
02:30.2
power Opo ba Paano po wagwag naman po
02:33.4
Hwag ka mag-alala Ma'am BP sa security
02:36.6
ko BP kasi may kinausap na ako na tao
02:40.6
sinabi ko sa kanya kapag pinatay ako
02:43.8
patayin mo si bbm si Lisa Araneta at si
02:47.4
Martin ralz no joke kitin po ako okay no
02:50.5
joke mga kabat natin so let's go here
02:53.9
no dito sa teleradyo serbisyo mga
02:57.2
kabatas natin may kinausap silang hab
02:59.8
abogado and this lawyer no was the
03:03.0
former IBP President una na nga diyan
03:06.1
partner ang ating top story of The
03:08.1
Weekend Ito nga pong naging mga pahayag
03:11.2
ni Vice President Sarah Duterte makakuha
03:14.2
po tayo ng reaksyon mula po sa
03:15.8
integrated bar of the Philippines
03:17.9
makakasama po natin ang kanilang past
03:19.9
president na si Attorney Domingo egon
03:21.9
kayosa Good morning po Attorney si
03:23.9
Christian po si Victoria Welcome back po
03:25.9
turn kayosa mga natin Sir good morning
03:29.2
Christian Victoria at Ah magandang umaga
03:31.4
sa nakikinig sa inyong programa OP at
03:33.5
ilinaw ko lang Christian This is I'm a
03:36.1
former President IBP does not have a
03:39.0
official stand and this matters these
03:40.6
are opinions from a lawyer just Okay Ito
03:43.2
kasing Gusto kong linawin no maraming
03:44.8
tao kasi ang ah humihingi ng official
03:48.4
statement from the integrated part of
03:49.9
the Philippines I think mga kabatas
03:52.2
natin It's a matter of respect okay and
03:56.7
Uh of course respect of the profession
04:00.2
first and foremost no and of course
04:02.5
respect of the people who are involved
04:05.5
in this particular issue kung bakit yung
04:09.5
mga IBP chapters ay hindi naglalabas o
04:12.4
kahit yung National na IBP ay hindi
04:14.2
naglalabas ng kanilang ano ng kanilang
04:17.2
mga statements in relation to this
04:21.3
this particular issue is very political
04:25.4
okay it's very Political and of course
04:28.0
we all know that Attorney VP VP saro
04:32.1
Duterte is an Attorney and also Attorney
04:35.3
Lopez okay and also there are lawyers in
04:38.1
the Quad Okay in the house of
04:42.1
representatives tapos Syempre lawyer din
04:44.0
si Lisa Marcos and this is highly
04:46.5
politicized p ako lang
04:48.4
no the IBP should not should not meddle
04:52.8
on this things especially when they give
04:56.8
out Okay their opinions in relation to
05:00.0
this should bees out in the proper venue
05:02.5
Pero itong mga natin si Attorney kayosa
05:05.2
nagsalita siya iniinterview din bilang
05:08.0
isang private lawyer Okay let's
05:11.8
go president of the IBP Thank you po sa
05:14.6
clarification attorney Opo So bilang
05:16.7
abogado Attorney on a standpoint of a
05:19.1
lawyer Itong mga naging pahayag po na
05:21.0
unang-una ni Vice President sar Ano ba
05:23.5
ang nakikita po natin na legal
05:26.0
implications po nito galing sa isang B
05:30.0
Of course it is very sad it is serious
05:32.7
siya mismo nagsasabing it is no joke it
05:35.3
is very sad it is very disruptive So
05:37.9
nakita niyo No it's very sad sabi niya
05:40.6
nakakalungkot nga naman kasi like I told
05:42.7
you mga natin That's a major
05:44.7
blunder from Vice President sar Duterte
05:47.9
Maraming problema ating bansa sana yung
05:49.8
mga hinalal nating matataas na opisyal
05:52.2
imes na mag-away-away Magtulungan para
05:54.2
bigyan ng solusyon yung matataas na
05:55.8
presyo Well that's the thing that's
05:58.3
ideal Kaya nga Nab yung uni team eh ' ba
06:01.4
magtutulungan sana sila pero
06:05.4
unfortunately pambubug na extreme lang
06:08.0
pala yyun mga biktima ng sakuna yung
06:10.7
West Philippine Sea yung ating ekonomya
06:13.4
at iba pa no So it is sabi ni Richard
06:16.6
Santos sana Pinahaba ni VP sara ang
06:19.2
kanyang Pasensya Tama si Attorney Levine
06:21.0
when the Emotions are high intelligence
06:23.2
is low Kaya dapat hindi nagbibigay ng
06:25.8
payag na ganon That's why I always tell
06:30.2
I always tell you to be reminded of that
06:32.8
kaya yun isa sa mga aphorisms o kaya isa
06:36.1
sa mga saying natin dito sa batas natin
06:38.8
because your feelings get you in trouble
06:41.0
aside from your feelings Your lack of
06:43.6
knowledge of the law gets you in trouble
06:46.6
Tingnan niyo kasi dito mga kabatas natin
06:48.4
itong si VP Sara Okay isa siyang
06:51.4
magaling na abogado pero tinalo siya ng
06:54.6
emosyon niya ' ba So dapat yun critical
06:58.6
thinking knowledge
07:02.4
tapos control over
07:05.0
feelings you should Master
07:07.7
those para you will not get in trouble
07:10.5
It's very Uh Unfortunate it is also
07:13.3
inappropriate if I may say lalonglalo na
07:16.2
Vice President ito for her to be doing
07:18.5
and saying those things no Uh It's also
07:21.1
very revealing na talagang Malala na ang
07:25.1
sitwasyon dito sa dating mga
07:28.0
at that's the sad part here din no Kasi
07:31.6
may nagsabi din sa akin na parang
07:33.2
Attorney Sana maayos pa yan sinabi rin
07:36.2
ni Attorney kayosa ' ba na talagang
07:39.2
malal na yung hidwaan sa sa parehong
07:41.5
panig sama sa pulitiko ah it is very sad
07:46.0
Nakakalungkot sapagkat ah inaasahan
07:48.7
nating taong bayan na yung ating
07:50.2
hinahalal at gumagawa gumagamit ng pondo
07:52.6
ng kaban ng bayan Eh positive at Ah yung
07:56.9
Ah isusulong yung kabutihan ng lahat at
07:59.6
hindi itong ah away nila an ah I suppose
08:03.4
from the point of view of the first lady
08:05.5
yeah tama away nga kasi ' ba priority
08:08.8
ang away kesa Doon ako nagagalit doon
08:13.8
tayo nagagalit you know that very well
08:15.5
mga natin That's why we don't like this
08:17.2
Congress Hearings na ito because it
08:18.9
results to this classing away it just
08:22.5
complicated pero At The End Of It All
08:25.2
Sino ang natalo Talo tayo pa rin kasi di
08:30.5
you can maybe say that This is drama and
08:32.9
entertainment kasi yun nga gusto ng
08:34.6
Pilipino ' ba pero At The End Of It All
08:38.4
We are still the losers nanduduon pa rin
08:41.2
si romualdes namimigay ng ayuda
08:44.1
akap tapos sabi ni professor shelo Magno
08:48.6
yung binibigay niyo na akap na yun
08:51.5
panuntunan tapos isipin niyo Saan tawag
08:55.2
lang ng SM may akap na my goodness
08:58.0
What's happening to the Philippines
08:60.0
kasi meron siyang mga kwan eh ang
09:01.6
binitawang very serious allegations of
09:03.8
offenses criminal acts on the part of
09:05.6
the first lady Uh if it is not true then
09:07.9
could be lius no sa aming profesyon
09:10.4
naman dahil well yung yyung mga paratang
09:13.2
Tama no it may be libelous pero syempre
09:17.5
If there is libel in relation to a
09:20.1
public figure Who is the first lady of
09:23.7
the Philippines Uh we need to Ano prove
09:27.1
actual malis okay Kaya nga sinabi niya
09:30.2
if it is not true kasi mga kabatas natin
09:34.0
no in public Figures when those
09:38.2
particular Uh particular information or
09:42.0
allegations na sinabi niya ay totoo and
09:45.7
It's a matter of public interest
09:48.7
Okay There Will Be no libel Okay let's
09:52.7
go abogada ang ating Vice President Uh
09:56.8
It Might amount to a violation of one ng
10:00.3
aming propesyon na a lawyer sh uphold
10:03.6
the constitution obey the grave threats
10:06.2
ba pasok Attorney Let's talk about it
10:08.0
later I have a case of the and promote
10:11.6
respect for law and for legal processes
10:14.4
Kung ikaw ay pangongontrata ng isang tao
10:17.9
isang grupo na papatay kung may mangyari
10:19.6
SAO eh Hindi naman yan respect for law
10:23.0
or for legal processes so I mentioned
10:25.3
you about the condition di ba i
10:27.6
mentioned you about the suspended
10:29.4
suspensive condition in relation to the
10:31.3
threats or Grave threats Let's talk
10:33.6
about that later Meron akong kaso Let's
10:35.7
just listen to ano muna to Attorney
10:38.1
kayosa that is very unethical conduct
10:40.8
not only as a lawyer but baka do din sa
10:44.1
ra 6713 code of conduct and ethical
10:47.1
standards for public officials and
10:49.0
employees Opo ito mga yan yung sinasabi
10:51.0
ko sa inyo mga kabatas natin Ano ho
10:52.8
lawyers have higher
10:55.1
standards and also public officials have
10:57.9
higher standards '
11:00.8
ba kaya ung mga mga ano mga kabatas
11:03.9
natin ung mga nagdudunung-dunungan diyan
11:05.7
na mas magaling daw sila sa abogado
11:07.6
tinatawag yung abogado na Bobo
11:12.7
muna mag-abogado ka muna kung nakapag
11:17.1
abogado ka na doon mo mag doon ka
11:19.4
magtawag ng bobo sa mga tao especially
11:22.6
sa kapwa mo lawyer kung lawyer ka na '
11:25.4
ba ganun lang naman kasimple e ung ung
11:27.8
fact na hindi ka pa lang makapag tapos
11:29.6
ng pag-aaral that says a lot already
11:32.9
Okay let's go m serious na pahayag po ni
11:36.9
VP Sara kung sakali po na ang gobyerno
11:39.4
ay kumilos dito Sino po ang dapat
11:40.9
manguna sir kung magi-invest diate pa ba
11:42.8
o mag-file Okay ito mga kaparis natin no
11:45.6
parang ah Paano ba makakasuhan daw si BP
11:48.1
saro Duterte Okay ng case well a ang ang
11:52.9
K number one na dapat no ah kahit walang
11:56.9
utos eh yung Presidential Security
11:58.9
command m kasi trabaho ng mga yan
12:00.9
naprotektahan ang presidente ah vice
12:03.6
president at yung mga ka-level nilang
12:07.0
dignitaries na pupunta sa atin so yan
12:09.2
naman hindi lang naman yan ah kagaya ng
12:11.7
pulis na AC mag-imbestiga kung may
12:13.4
nangyari na so mga preventive dapat
12:15.9
i-verify nila Meron Ba t so ito in
12:18.9
relation to investigation naman yung
12:20.4
sinasabi niya not necessarily filing of
12:22.2
cases pa okay ba itong kinontrata niya
12:25.4
kasi malinaw yung kanyang sinabi na
12:27.7
meron na siyang kinontrata hindi nga
12:29.3
lang niyang sinasabi kung tao isang tao
12:31.1
o grupo so dapat ah Tingnan nila kung
12:33.3
totoo yan ah mag-invest at ah Kung meron
12:37.0
man eh kinakailangang ah they take
12:39.8
preventive action so yan pangalawa yung
12:42.7
um first lady kasi siya yyung private
12:45.7
offended party doon sa libelous maaring
12:48.1
libelous Mar ito sinabi niya private
12:50.8
offended party si first lady I don't
12:53.8
believe na no na private offended party
12:56.9
si first lady ay think Uh the first lady
13:00.8
is already propelled in a particular
13:03.3
position for her to be considered as a
13:05.8
public figure kasi nga mga kabatas natin
13:08.6
no lumalabas din siya sa media Kilala
13:11.4
siya ng maraming tao kasi naalala niyo
13:14.4
yung ating ano no yyung ating
13:17.0
ah usapan tungkol sa public Figures na
13:20.4
defined by The supreme court Okay the
13:22.9
the the Supreme Court defined a public
13:26.8
figure No one one of Uh one particular
13:30.5
instance kung saan pwede ka maging
13:31.9
public figure eh kung nagkaroon ng
13:34.3
instance Okay event
13:38.3
o happening pagkakataon kung saan you've
13:43.3
been thrust into the position of a
13:46.8
public figure itong si ano kasi mga
13:49.4
kabatas natin itong si ah Attorney Lisa
13:53.3
Marcos sa pagiging sobrang sikat niya
13:55.4
naging public figure na rin siya Tapos
13:57.4
nagpaunlak na rin siya ng s interviews
14:00.0
mga kabatas natin from several
14:02.2
personalities vloggers news news ah Ano
14:06.9
tawag diyan ah news men news women Okay
14:11.0
na-feature niya yung buhay niya tapos
14:13.8
nagpaliwanag na siya
14:16.7
So she is she is a public figure Okay
14:21.0
alam na nga natin lahat n talang buhay
14:22.9
niya e ' ba alam na natin yung
14:24.9
talambuhay niya kasi ilang beses na
14:26.9
nagpa-interview siya sin yung love story
14:30.2
nila ni ni ano ni Marcos pati yung
14:33.0
hidwaan nila ni VP Sara kung paano ito
14:36.0
nagsimula di ba we all know that already
14:38.9
so she is a public figure so I Believe
14:41.8
mga kabatas natin na still We need
14:45.2
actual malis Kaya nga sabi niya if it
14:47.1
were not true kapag ito mga kabatas
14:50.1
natin no mga paninirang ginawa sa kanya
14:54.7
and Attorney Lisa Marcos is considered
14:58.0
as a private figure
14:59.7
no private individual whether or not
15:03.1
these are true Okay they can be a ground
15:07.4
for filing a case of libel Okay let's go
15:11.9
Sabi niya siya yung pasimuno nung panun
15:14.4
sa mga kawan ng gobyerno si pa nagturo
15:18.0
kanya pangatlo naman yung Department of
15:22.6
merong possible violation revised Penal
15:25.9
Code yung iba sinasabing great threats
15:29.0
ah ung iba naman sa think ko ung mas
15:30.7
plausible ung attempted murder kasi when
15:32.8
you contract Somebody To To Kill
15:35.5
particular persons and you agree on it
15:37.2
already eh baka mahulog na attempted
15:39.6
stage Ian ng morder Okay so attempted
15:42.4
yun yung kinaso nila Grave yung kinaso
15:45.7
kaso na pinag Iniisip nila ' ba Grave
15:49.0
threats na pag-usapan din natin yan
15:50.9
tapos attempted murder daw tignan natin
15:53.5
yung kanyang explanation ah sa aming mga
15:56.6
abogado naman any Citizen any lawyer
16:00.3
Sue IBP can without investigate itwa
16:06.0
number one ethical cond yung pagmumura
16:08.6
at marami ng mga abogado ang naparusahan
16:11.5
dahil sa pagmumura Pangalawa ang ethical
16:14.4
cond din yung pag agrabyado ka o kaya sa
16:17.4
tingin mo may threat SAO ang gagawin mo
16:19.6
mangontrata ka ng isang tao isang grupo
16:21.8
para patayin din yung tatlong tao not
16:24.3
respect for law or
16:26.2
process ito ang sinasabi niya mga natin
16:29.2
no Eh ano yan Anong tawag diyan um
16:33.7
ah administrative sanctions ng isang
16:36.4
abogado Okay Canon one of our code of
16:39.5
conduct of bilang lawyers so ito yyung
16:43.0
Mga posibleng legal implications or
16:46.6
legal moves na kaharap niya Pwede rin
16:49.9
yyung political yyung impeachment but
16:51.5
that is left to the wisdom and
16:54.0
discretion of the lower house mga
16:56.2
congressman Opo pero on the other side
16:58.0
din atorney na mention nio rin kanina no
16:59.8
Alam niyo sa tingin ko mga kabatas natin
17:01.6
Ano based on What's happening Right now
17:05.2
I'm kinda I'm kind of thinking mga
17:08.1
kabatas natin na ang pinaka
17:09.6
kino-consider ngayon ng lower house ay
17:13.7
itong pagpa-file ng impeachment
17:15.6
complaint against BP Sara Kaya nga
17:17.3
sinabi ko This is a blunder I think yan
17:19.6
yung pinag-iisipan nila ngayon
17:22.5
kasi they want to get rid of her if they
17:25.2
get rid of her that's good for them
17:29.5
doun sa mga binanggit ni BP Sara meron
17:31.5
din siyang mga binitiwang accusations '
17:33.4
ba may mga binanggit siyang official si
17:35.2
first lady may binanggit din siyang mga
17:37.2
sobre Ah do you think kailangan din itg
17:39.4
imbestigahan naman din on the other side
17:41.0
ng mga official kasi Although lahat tayo
17:43.3
nakatutok doon sa mga mabibigat niyang
17:45.1
threat pero meron din siyang binanggit
17:46.7
na mga accusation sino din ang dapat na
17:48.3
tumingin doon atorney sa mga sinabi na
17:50.3
yon ng B presidente magandang punto yan
17:53.0
no very serious Yung kanyang sinabi ang
17:54.8
problema lang kasi sabi lang niya wala
17:57.2
siyang pinapakitang dokumento walang
18:00.9
Wang So kung talagang Totoo yon ang
18:03.8
maganda rin niyang gawin eh ilantad niya
18:05.9
lahat yan kasi pag nandyan na yon
18:07.3
kumbaga may meron ng sapat na basehan
18:10.7
Pwede rin niang imbestigahan ng kongreso
18:12.8
pwede ring imbestigahan yan ng ombudsman
18:14.9
at kung sino-sino man hindi rin ho kasi
18:17.1
na dahil may sinabi ka lang na ginawang
18:19.6
masama o krimen isang tao kaagad May
18:21.2
imbestigasyon you have to offer enough
18:24.1
Quantum of evidence para naman nakikita
18:26.9
ng Imbestigador na merong patutungo ito
18:29.4
ah hindi naman lahat kasi ng allegation
18:31.5
eh papatulan ng mga Imbestigador ng PNP
18:34.6
o ng DOJ o kaya ng ombudsman
18:37.0
kinakailangan naman meron kang
18:39.2
corroborating evidence meron kang mga
18:41.6
dokumento gaya ng nangyayari ngayon
18:43.4
saung mga imbestigasyon halimbawa quc ng
18:46.1
kongreso o yung ginagawa well alam niyo
18:48.9
yan kasi yung problema ko talaga dito sa
18:53.2
Sara that's the problem here doon ka
18:57.0
pwedeng makaon sa ganyan a I'm all for
18:59.3
transparency transparency
19:01.9
meron kaming mga pareho na pinaglalaban
19:06.3
almost all of the the the political
19:10.9
problems that we have we cited here in
19:13.7
batas natin VP Sara is also against it
19:18.2
pero ako against din ako sa pagmumura
19:21.7
kasi nga tama yung sinabi niya ginagaya
19:23.7
ng mga bata yan tapos syempre when
19:26.1
Emotions are high
19:31.5
Alam niyo na yung kasunod ng kapulisan
19:34.1
at ng ng DOJ na hindi lahat ng parata
19:39.0
papatulan kinakailangan obligasyon din
19:41.4
nagar na yung mga supporting documents
19:46.0
supporting facts Witnesses paraanin that
19:49.3
This is worth investigating
19:51.7
soor do agree with malang to call it
19:59.0
na ito ito ito Tingan natin of
20:02.6
course Hindi Sabi niya mismo It's not a
20:05.3
joke Plus may maintindihan ko sana kung
20:08.2
isang ah tricycle driver ang magsabing
20:10.8
nr na ako na may papatay sa presidente
20:14.2
Actually agree here also si S generis ba
20:17.1
yyun o si underoath yung nagsabi na ano
20:20.5
dito sa Grave threat na ito I agreed
20:23.2
also Vice President at saka speaker of
20:26.0
the house eh Medyo kalokohan lang yan
20:28.2
pag h lang yan eh ito Vice President eh
20:30.6
at malinaw na meron silang away so it is
20:34.0
an active threat so maganda na natignan
20:37.1
nila whether or not it amounts to yyung
20:39.8
Uh great threat na criminal under the
20:42.9
revised Penal is another thing they have
20:45.1
to look into that or baka nga mas
20:47.1
appropriate yung attempted murder Kasi
20:48.6
ngaung sabi pag Papatay ka ng tao at
20:50.3
mangontrata ka ng papatay murder yon So
20:54.1
pero yung attempted kasi alam nio siguro
20:56.8
yun yung una nating ano no yun yung una
20:59.5
nating pag-usapan yung attempted murder
21:03.3
okay yung attempted murder syempre may
21:09.8
yan Okay ang attempted murder parang
21:13.5
attempted homicide din yan pero pag
21:16.9
merong ano qualifying aggravating
21:20.2
circumstance dito ang qualifying
21:22.9
aggravating circumstance mga kabatas
21:25.0
natin ay yung evident premeditation ano
21:28.4
yung evident premeditation yung
21:31.4
okay pinagplanuhan yun so Punta na tayo
21:35.0
dito okay tulad nga ng sinabi ko We will
21:38.0
be very academic scholarly this time
21:41.4
Okay sabi niyang ganyan no the elements
21:44.4
of frustrated homicide so tulad ng
21:46.8
sinabi ko sa inyo no ah ang homicide ay
21:49.4
pagpatay din ng tao pero dito kasi wala
21:51.9
siyang qualifying aggravating
21:53.9
circumstance kaya kaya ang sinabi niya
21:59.3
murder kasi nga meron silang sinasabing
22:03.0
qualifying aggravating circumstance
22:05.0
which is yung evident premeditation kasi
22:07.9
syempre pag mangontrata ka pag
22:09.6
paplanuhin niyo kung paano patayin ang
22:11.8
isang tao Paano nga daw siya papatayin
22:13.7
pag pinatay ako patayin niyo rin siya di
22:16.9
ba at tapos dito mga kabatas natin ang
22:20.2
number one the accuse intended to kill
22:22.3
his victim as manifested by his use of a
22:25.2
deadly weapon in the assault
22:28.9
the victim sustained fatal or Mortal
22:31.4
wounds but did not die because of timely
22:34.9
assistance None of the qualifying
22:37.3
circumstance for murder o ito Sabi niya
22:40.4
under article 248 of the revised Penal
22:43.6
Code as amended is present o wala Iyung
22:46.3
number three dito kasi nga pag present
22:48.2
yyan murder na so dito number three
22:51.2
present yyung isang qualifying
22:53.1
aggravating circumstance which is
22:55.8
evident premeditation so
22:59.6
murder ang pinag-uusapan natin pero pag
23:02.0
titignan niyo kasi mga kabatas natin
23:03.6
It's very necessary in relation to Ano
23:06.8
ay frustrated pala ito attempted pala
23:09.3
yung sinabi niya ' ba Well anyway
23:11.4
pag-usapan na lang natin ito pag-usapan
23:13.7
natin ito kasi iba yyung ano the victim
23:15.7
sustained fatal or Mortal wounds okay
23:19.7
ito kaya pala Okay okay the victim
23:22.4
sustain fatal or Mortal wounds but did
23:24.1
not die because of timely medical
23:26.1
assistance kaya yan yung nadan kasi ito
23:28.8
mga kbs natin frustrated homicide
23:31.5
magkaiba yun sa attempted murder Okay
23:35.0
magkaiba yon So ito meron ng Mortal
23:39.1
wound Okay so Anyway idi-discuss ko rin
23:41.9
naman kasi ito iba lang yung naipalabas
23:59.2
okay because of timely medical
24:02.2
assistance okay ngayon Syempre wala ring
24:05.8
intensyon to kill the victim as the
24:07.9
manifest manifested by the use of a
24:10.7
deadly weapon pag frustrated kasi ang
24:13.0
isang ang isang ano mga kats natin Ken
24:16.1
eh nagawa mo na o naumpisahan mo ng
24:18.8
gawin yung Ken pero hindi mo na-achieve
24:21.9
yung purpose mo kasi nga nagkaroon ng
24:25.5
medic untimely medical atten so dito mga
24:32.3
eh may overt a dito kay VP Sara walang
24:38.9
overt Acts of Actually executing the
24:43.9
murder Okay so ngayon Punta tayo no
24:59.0
Sandali Sandali ilabas ko naclose ko
25:07.2
ah dito tayo generally okay
25:35.4
ito papakita ko muna yyung citation sa
25:41.2
ito this is GR number 203 435 April 11
25:47.6
2018 people of the Philippines versus
25:50.4
Aquino Okay yan yung kasong yan Yan yung
25:53.5
frustrated stage magkaiba yan okay oh
25:57.8
Dito rin mga kabatas natin
26:00.6
ha Okay ito naman kasong Ito okay This
26:07.5
is Uh a 2020 case February February 17
26:11.8
2020 GR number 238 438
26:16.5
kasilak versus people of the Philippines
26:19.7
okay pag titingnan niyo dito diniscuss
26:23.9
no yung elements of the Crime Of murder
26:29.0
Okay the element should be that a person
26:32.2
was killed that the accused killed him
26:34.9
or her and that the killing was attended
26:37.3
by any of the qualifying circumstances
26:39.6
mentioned so dito wala pang killing so
26:42.3
hindi natin nga masasabi na consummated
26:45.6
yyung crime so tandaan niyo yyung stages
26:47.6
of Commission of Commission of the
26:49.7
Commission of a crime yyung attempted
26:51.8
stage yun yung pinaka pinakauna Okay na
26:56.0
pinakamababa kapag kunwari may kmin na
26:58.5
usapan Tapos yung frustrated stage yun
27:01.0
ung yun ung pinag-usapan natin kanina
27:03.4
kung saan nag-excuse na siya ng mga
27:05.6
elements ng crime pero hindi niya
27:07.2
na-achieve yung purpose niya dahil sa
27:09.5
isang bagay na hindi naman niya
27:11.5
kagustuhan Okay tapos yung consummated
27:14.3
stage yun na yung tapos lahat kung
27:16.8
napatay na yung tao Okay so dito mga
27:22.2
merong definition din ng attempted
27:26.5
felony okay Ano ba ang elements ng
27:31.8
isang attempted felony ito the essential
27:36.2
elements of an attempted felony kasi ang
27:38.8
sinasabi nila a attempted murder daw di
27:41.0
ba the offender commences the Commission
27:43.7
of the felony directly by overt acts
27:47.3
Okay so ang tanong diyan mga kabatas
27:52.2
yung yung pag-hire
27:56.0
mo okay pag hire mo ng
28:01.5
Assassin does that already
28:07.6
okay Commission of a felony directly by
28:12.7
acts Okay the simple answer mga kabatas
28:16.8
natin it may be an element of the felony
28:22.8
is What's that conspiracy ' ba kasi
28:30.2
you still you will prove conspiracy din
28:33.0
and it is an element of the Crime kapag
28:36.2
there are several people who Actually
28:39.9
are participating on it Okay pero mga
28:43.8
kabatas natin strictly
28:46.4
speaking kasi syempre yung
28:49.2
pagpaplano element of the Crime yung
28:51.6
pagpaplano conspiracy ito eh Ano ang
28:55.0
pangatlong element ng crime doon sa
28:59.3
murder muna murder Ano ang isang element
29:02.4
ng crime doon sa murder number three
29:05.2
element ba aggravating
29:08.1
circumstance ang aggravating
29:09.9
circumstance qualifying Sorry qualifying
29:12.3
aggravating circumstance ang qualifying
29:14.5
aggravating circumstance do mga kabatas
29:16.6
natin yung pagpaplano which
29:19.6
is considered evident premeditation so
29:24.3
that is already the number three element
29:28.3
in the Crime Of murder which is a
29:31.4
qualifying aggravating circumstance ' ba
29:35.0
So the offender commences the Commission
29:37.9
of the Uh the felony directly by overt
29:41.8
acts di ba Pinasok mo na di ba elements
29:46.7
nag-comment ka nag-comment ka na
29:48.2
nag-comment ka na Pumasok na di ba he
29:50.9
does not perform all the Acts of the
29:53.1
execution which should produce the
29:55.2
felony dito kasi mga kabatas natin
29:59.1
no dito eh Hindi niya natapos
30:05.2
ito dapat mangyayari na the offenders
30:08.9
act be not stopped by his own
30:10.9
spontaneous desistance ibig sabihin
30:12.9
niyan hindi siya yyung umatras para
30:15.4
gawin yung krimen na iyon ' ba tapos ito
30:20.4
the non performance of all Acts of
30:22.5
execution was due to cause or accident
30:25.0
other than his spontaneous desistance
30:28.3
sabi niya ito ang problema ko kasi dito
30:33.7
natin ito ang problema ko dito yung
30:37.6
sinabi ni VP sar na no joke ba may n
30:43.5
sinabihan na siya na pag pinatay ako
30:45.8
Patayin mo itong tatlong
30:48.8
Ito ba Patayin mo yung tatlong ito so
30:52.5
commences the Commission of theon
30:58.3
kasi dito mga kabatas natin verbal yung
31:05.2
Sara yung sinabi niya na yon a
31:09.8
verbal walang overt acts in relation to
31:15.5
the Commission of the
31:17.0
felony kumbaga mga kats natin Ano ba
31:19.9
yung pinaka element doon ' ba yung yung
31:24.1
mag gagawa ka ng ano ' ba yung
31:59.1
Sorry frustrated attempted murder yun o
32:05.0
kasi wala namang overt action kung saan
32:11.3
yung mga elemento ng
32:14.9
krimen ba So Ito paano ba siya ikakahon
32:18.6
dito Hanapin niyo yung tao na Kinausap
32:21.5
niya i-prove niyo na Kinausap niya ngay
32:26.8
yon yun yung una niyong gagawin para
32:30.2
maipakita na there was
32:32.8
actually pag-uusap di ba which is part
32:38.3
of the elements of the
32:40.9
Crime directly by overt acts na Nangyari
32:48.6
ba so hindi kung kung ang ebidensya niyo
32:53.0
lang kung ang ebidensya niyo lang ay
32:55.3
yung pagsabi niya na yon
33:01.1
opinion mas Grave threat siya kaya
33:06.2
murder Although Yun nga ung element pero
33:09.0
syempre You have to know you have to
33:10.9
execute It by over tax yung sinabi niya
33:13.8
naman na may nakausap na ako hindi naman
33:15.8
niya sinabi hindi naman hindi niyo naman
33:19.0
nawitness o wala naman kayong ebidensya
33:21.3
talaga na Nangyari yun kasi pwedeng
33:23.1
nananakot lang siya katulad ng sinasabi
33:27.4
ng mga tao sa Grave
33:29.6
threats kasi kung sinabi mong papatayin
33:32.8
kita o kaya ipapapatay kita Ang kaso
33:36.1
doon Grave threats at
33:44.5
murder gets ' ba ganun
33:49.0
yun Otherwise mga kabatas natin p ano
33:54.2
kita frustrate attempted murder taas
33:58.0
kasi yung penalty ng attempted murder of
34:02.9
oh sabi ni jingo Kay ano panero tama ka
34:06.7
walang Corpus delic '
34:09.0
ba yun kasi pag titignan mo
34:13.5
dito sa kaso naman in relation
34:18.5
to to Ano to Grave threats ito ha Grave
34:25.2
Ah pero tandaan niyo mga kuds natin wala
34:27.9
tayong pinaparatangan dito ah This this
34:30.5
is a discussion that is purely academic
34:33.3
amounting to yung ganon yung mga sinabi
34:36.0
ni bb Sara doon okay Yun lang well like
34:40.1
I said we treat them as a hypothetical
34:42.4
baka meron na namang mag wala-wala diyan
34:45.1
GR number 2483 17 March 16
34:50.2
2022 Okay ano ang sinabi niya
34:54.2
dito ang sinabi niya dito
34:58.0
patayin ka koman Papatayin na sana kita
35:01.3
Pero dito naakit siya okay naakit siya
35:04.3
kasi nga ah hindi naman nila napatunayan
35:07.2
nagkaroon ng reasonable doubt Pero kung
35:09.6
bakit umakyat ito sa Supreme Court kasi
35:12.1
nga Ilocano to ha Patayin ka k man
35:14.8
Papatayin na sana kita So may kison kaya
35:18.6
ito yung pinili ko kasi sabi niya p
35:22.2
kasama ka lang sana doon o kasama mo
35:24.8
sila ganon parang ganun yung kondisyon
35:30.3
kita sabi niya pero parang hindi kasi
35:33.0
kasama kaya hindi pinatay di ba sabi
35:36.1
dito mga kabatas natin sa Grave threats
35:38.8
Okay Grave threats sabi niya okay the
35:42.2
penalty next lower in degree than the
35:44.3
prescribed by law of the Crime be
35:46.2
threatened to commit if the offender
35:48.0
shall have made the threat demanding
35:49.5
money or imposing any other
35:52.8
condition sabi niya
35:56.1
oh even though not unlawful and said
35:59.4
offender shall have attain this purpose
36:01.5
blah blah blah blah ito kasi mga kabatas
36:07.8
diyan demanding money or imposing any
36:15.8
yan so dito napakalawak nung sinabi na
36:19.7
any other condition
36:29.5
yan Ito ito naman aresto Mayor naman
36:35.2
kis So it will not matter Actually kung
36:38.0
ano yung condition kasi sinabi
36:43.0
dito kahit yung condition e not
36:48.7
unlawful So ibig sabihin kahit anong
36:56.0
kond so my opinion mga kabatas natin ang
36:59.2
pinakamalapit lang no na pwede Malamang
37:06.9
threats kasi regardless of the condition
37:09.4
eh ito even though not unlawful ito
37:19.8
1 ito Meron pa dito if if if it's made
37:24.1
in writing or through a
37:28.1
period Grave threats pa rin pero I think
37:31.8
it's it's very far Reaching na kapag
37:34.6
yung kaso ay ah kasi mas nakakatakot
37:40.0
eh hindi ako hindi ko kabisado masyado
37:43.0
yung penalty Okay so ire-renew
37:58.2
mas masakit kasi sa tenga Yung attempted
38:00.3
murder kasi talagang ah Parang gusto
38:02.6
mong pumatay ng tao doon pero tulad nga
38:05.2
ng sinabi ko Hindi ho sa tingin ko
38:07.0
mangyayari yung attempted murder dito
38:09.0
kung yun lang ang ebidensya natin yung
38:11.2
sinabi ni ni ano ni VP Sara na iyon kasi
38:15.6
there is Actually no proof na There Was
38:21.5
commencement or execution of the Crime
38:24.0
already through overt acts kasi nga ang
38:26.4
sinabi niya lang ay isang verbal
38:28.6
threat which may fall under Grave
38:32.2
threats ' ba ' ba your game is sc shame
38:37.0
attempted is too far fetched kasi ito
38:39.2
rin yyung sinasabi dito ni ano eh ni
38:42.2
yyung in-interview nilaa dito ' ba it
38:47.1
reach yyung great thre na criminal under
38:50.7
the revis Penal Code is another Thing We
38:53.2
have to look into that or baka nga mas
38:55.2
appropriate yung attempted murder kasi
38:56.8
nga ppatay ka ng tao mangontrata ka ng
38:59.3
papatay murder yon So Oo pag nangun
39:19.0
pero syempre kailangan mo kasing i-prove
39:21.9
yung elements eh So pwede ba maging
39:25.0
element yung sinabi niya lang na yon
39:29.3
pwede naman kasi naimbento niya lang yan
39:31.3
eh Syempre kung ano lang yung
39:33.0
mapapatunayan mo sa korte yun lang
39:38.7
yun ' ba i think yung pag sabi niya na
39:42.8
no joke ay pwede pasok sa
39:45.2
serious I think Grave threats if ever
39:48.0
There is something here
39:50.4
no Ah Ah ito si kyb Tama no in relation
39:55.4
to cyber crime law may cyber crime law
39:57.4
pa pala so papasok din yun tataas din
40:00.1
ung penalty niya dahil sa cyber crime
40:04.4
law ' ba Attorney news dito sa hk
40:08.9
nag-arrange daw si VP ng Assassin well
40:11.6
Ganon talaga yung ma i-interpret mo doon
40:14.5
kasi It's very blatant naman eh Pero yun
40:18.8
ganon pero as far as that particular
40:23.4
video is concerned Grave threats kasi
40:27.9
pwedeng pumasok yung mga elemento niya
40:29.7
non pero yung parang nag-crack siya ng
40:31.5
Assassin e' Syempre kailangan mong
40:34.0
patunayan na nag-crack siya Actually ng
40:35.9
Assassin din doon para pumasok na
40:38.5
nacomments yung pag pagpapapatay na yon
40:42.2
' ba kasi pwede naman sabihin nila na
40:44.5
ano eh na Sabi ko nga sa inyo when
40:47.0
Emotions are high intelligence is low
40:49.6
okay Ah yun lang mga kats natin sana
40:53.4
malinaw na yan no eh nagpalabas naman na
40:56.1
ako ng mga prueba sa inyo
40:58.0
Okay maraming salamat Syempre tuloy ng
41:00.8
Lagi kong sinasabi matulog po tayo ng
41:02.7
mahimbing dahil alam natin naung
41:04.5
natutulog na mahimbing siya laging
41:07.1
panalo Paalam po pansamantala
