ATO VS TITO MARS 2 FEAT MATT WALSH - GENDER DEBATE NG MGA TAMBAY - Is Gender Roles an Illusion?
00:58.0
Flowers, flowers to me
01:00.0
Flowers to me, flowers to me
01:03.0
Shed ascending flowers, come back to me
01:06.0
And hold me in your arms, arms, arms
01:09.0
Sending flowers to me
01:11.0
Send me no flowers today
01:14.0
Shed ascending flowers, come back to me
01:16.0
And hold me in your arms again
01:21.0
You've been sending flowers to me
01:23.0
Send me no flowers today
01:26.0
Shed ascending flowers, come back to me
01:28.0
And hold me in your arms again
01:32.0
Ever since the day that you went away
01:34.0
You went away, you went away
01:37.0
Ever since the day that you went away
01:40.0
You went away, you went away
01:44.0
You went away, you went away
01:47.0
You went away, ever since the day that you went away
01:51.0
You went away, you went away
01:54.0
You've been sending flowers
01:57.0
How's it going mga kamates, mga kaibigan
01:59.0
And welcome back to another livestream
02:03.0
So kamusta kayo dyan?
02:05.0
Sino ba to? Si Oliver Tagal
02:08.0
Sorry po kung matagal, medyo may inaayos lang tayo
02:11.0
And then, alam nyo naman, busy-busyhan
02:14.0
And MJ Senar, hello
02:17.0
KP3 Kings game na, good evening po
02:21.0
Sendi nakikinig habang maliligo papasok sa work
02:23.0
Yan, magandang trip yan
02:25.0
Kasi this is something really important sa tingin ko mga kamates, mga kaibigan
02:29.0
Kasi nga, of course uso na kasing magturo sa internet ngayon
02:35.0
Anyone can have an opinion on anything
02:37.0
Wala naman akong problema dun
02:39.0
Pero sana lang, you form your opinions
02:47.0
At least man lang, meron tayong scientific basis
02:50.0
Para meron tayong connecta sa objective reality na tinatawag
02:54.0
Or something that is measurable
02:59.0
Kasi basically, yun lang naman talaga ang sinasabi ng sciences
03:06.0
Something that you can measure
03:08.0
Something that everyone can agree upon
03:10.0
Renzel Im, shoutouts
03:12.0
Supaeng, shoutouts
03:14.0
Ann, hello umabot
03:16.0
Hello sa'yo Ann, naparating na sa
03:18.0
Nagta-travel-travel
03:20.0
Kim Kasing, kain tayo boss, maraming salamat
03:23.0
DJ YouTube, hello
03:27.0
Pinapatawag mo kaming lahat, notified
03:29.0
Yun, yun, yun, yun
03:31.0
Sa wakas, yun na-notified na rin
03:33.0
Kain while watching your live, nice
03:35.0
Okay, so ano lang to
03:37.0
This is part 2 of our
03:39.0
Yung gender topic na pinag-uusapan ni Ato at saka ni Tito Mars
03:43.0
I think kasi it's very important now
03:46.0
Na pag-uusapan natin yan
03:48.0
Dumadami na kasi yung opinion about sa gender role, sa gender identity na yan
03:53.0
I want you guys to have an objective look dito
03:56.0
Kasi ang hindi ko lang gusto talaga
03:58.0
Kapag kami mga, pag-mema lang
04:01.0
Na ito dapat yung gawin ng babae
04:03.0
Ito dapat yung gawin ng lalaki
04:05.0
Tapos yung, yung nagpapayo sa'yo ni hindi nga babae
04:08.0
Or at least wala siyang experience maging babae
04:12.0
Or itratuhin ng isang boyfriend
04:14.0
So, it's all conjecture na out of
04:18.0
Alam niyo ba yung talking from outside your ass?
04:21.0
Parang gano'n yun e
04:23.0
Bosnik's Gender Debate Meta, oo nga gano'n talaga e
04:26.0
Sabi ni Enwat, nakaabot ka tapos maglakas
04:31.0
Hoy Sir Mark, hello sa'yo
04:33.0
Thank you so much for joining the Armada
04:38.0
Okay, so nung isang araw pinag-uusapan natin yung definition ng gender
04:44.0
Okay, so refresher muna tayo dun sa unang live natin
04:48.0
So kung hindi niyo natatandaan yung unang live
04:50.0
Teka lang, lagay natin to dito and then dito
04:54.0
Okay, so yung unang live natin mga kamates, mga kaibigan
04:57.0
Pinag-uusapan natin dun yung what is gender
05:02.0
Yung definition ko to ha
05:04.0
Ang gender dapat, ang definition nito is a measurement of one's sex due at birth
05:11.0
Paano ba nade-determine yan?
05:13.0
Hoy Mark, thank you so much sa 2 Singaporean Dollars
05:19.0
Badz Abrenicam, nakaabot din pa shoutout Bosnik
05:22.0
Shoutout sa'yo Badz
05:23.0
So, ibig sabihin nun mga kamates, mga kaibigan
05:27.0
Kasi meron naman kasing gender signifier na tinatawag
05:31.0
Ibig sabihin nun, pag tinignan mo yung are nung bagong panganak na bata
05:36.0
Automatic malalaman mo na kung babae o lalaki yun
05:39.0
Kung hindi apparent yun, you can check for chromosomes
05:43.0
You can check for hormones
05:45.0
So, there are a lot of ways para ma-determine ang isang gender ng bata
05:49.0
Objective measurements para malaman ang gender ng bata during birth
05:55.0
Ngayon, meron tayong mga hermaphrodite na tinatawag
05:58.0
These are called statistical outliers
06:01.0
Ibig sabihin, yes, they exist
06:04.0
We are aware that they exist
06:06.0
Pero since they are outliers, we cannot normalize them
06:11.0
We cannot include them in the definition of gender for everyone
06:17.0
Yung normalized yung sinasabi natin
06:20.0
So, therefore, at birth, mga kamates, mga kaibigan
06:23.0
There are only two genders
06:25.0
Okay, maliwanag ba yan?
06:27.0
Now, gender identity naman is after the fact of gender
06:31.0
After mong ma-measure yung gender, you can have a subjective take on gender
06:37.0
Gender is, nasa spectrum kasi yung
06:41.0
Nasa spectrum kasi yung gender identity
06:46.0
Eto yung mga nasa LGBTQ community
06:50.0
You need to understand that these two things are fundamentally different
06:57.0
Gender talks about the measurement of one's sex at birth
07:02.0
Yung gender identity naman talks about what you feel inside
07:08.0
This is objective reality
07:10.0
This is subjective
07:12.0
Nakaintindihan ba?
07:13.0
This is based on facts
07:15.0
This is slightly based on your opinion
07:18.0
Or is based fundamentally on your opinion
07:22.0
Nakukuha ba mga kamates, mga kaibigan kung ano yung difference nito?
07:25.0
Kasi dito tayo dapat mag-focus
07:28.0
Kasi, for example, if Mr. Tito Mars says na
07:33.0
Paparinig ko na lang yung sinabi niya sa inyo para mayroon tayong example
07:37.0
Why this definition is very important
07:42.0
Kasi medyo maganda yung viewership natin sa nd.gg
07:46.0
Guys, eto muna yung official page ko
07:49.0
Binabawi pa kasi namin yung isang page ko na may 300,000 followers
07:54.0
Tinatray nating bawiin yun
08:02.0
By saying na, hindi parkit marami yung following mo
08:05.0
Is you have the right to bully someone
08:08.0
Most specially minority
08:10.0
As a gay, I'm included in minorities
08:13.0
Okay, so nakikita niyo ba yung difference na yun?
08:16.0
In-include niya yung sarili niya sa minority
08:19.0
Kasi nga member siya ng LGBTQ community
08:22.0
Pero, when we are
08:24.0
When you say that you are a member of a minority group
08:29.0
You don't have a choice in it
08:32.0
Halimbawa, PWD ka, diba?
08:37.0
Ayun, both sex and gender are two different things
08:40.0
Yung definition ko is very clear dito, brother
08:43.0
Para hindi tayo magkagulo-gulo
08:47.0
Dinistinguish ko yung gender sa gender identity
08:54.0
Kasi pag sinabi natin yung sex na word
09:00.0
I do think na it's leaning towards
09:04.0
Una-una, hindi siya colloquially acceptable
09:08.0
Or hindi siya word na
09:10.0
Alam mo yung pag sinabi mo yung word na yan
09:13.0
May kikiligin, may iba yung iisipin
09:15.0
So, for the sake of colloquial discussions
09:19.0
I'm defining gender and gender identity as two different things
09:23.0
Hindi yung sex and gender
09:27.0
So, gusto ko lang pagkaibahin yun
09:29.0
Kasi meron kasing yung gender at birth
09:33.0
Parang mas tama siguro yun
09:35.0
But for the sake of discussion dito
09:37.0
And for the sake of-
09:38.0
Dahil nasa Pilipinas tayo
09:40.0
Mamaya, Mr. Nico Fuliente
09:42.0
May explain ko sa iyo yung aking rationale
09:45.0
Why am I doing these discussions on gender identity
09:54.0
And gender, ano, ano ba ngayon?
09:55.0
Gender ideology tayo ngayon, eh
09:58.0
And gender roles tayo ngayon
09:59.0
Gender roles and gender ideology tayo ngayon
10:02.0
Ito yung dalawang konsep na pag-aaralan natin, eh
10:04.0
Dito, ah, based on science
10:06.0
Not based on your feelings, okay?
10:08.0
Your feelings doesn't matter here in my channel, okay?
10:11.0
It matters a little, pero
10:13.0
You know, minsan masakit talaga ito, eh
10:19.0
Basahin natin yung kay Joshua Jed
10:22.0
Si Joshua Jed, nakuha niya yung point ko
10:24.0
I agree with you, Sir Nick
10:25.0
Sermopredent is a congenital defect
10:27.0
Po, developed niya in the first trimester of pregnancy
10:30.0
See? It's a congenital defect
10:32.0
So, it's not part of the norm
10:34.0
Welcome back to the Armada, Maruko!
10:40.0
Aba, Maruko, mukhang ano na, ha
10:42.0
Mukhang okay nang
10:44.0
Ano, sasabihin ko lang sa inyo, ha
10:47.0
Medyo magta-time-press lang muna ako dito sa, ano
10:49.0
Hindi ko kayo nire-required na sumali sa Armada
10:52.0
Of course, if you want to join
10:55.0
Mas maganda para sa akin
10:57.0
But you are not required to join
10:59.0
Ang requirement yun lang
11:00.0
I-like nyo yung video ko
11:04.0
Goods na ako dun, pare
11:05.0
I-share nyo yung mga natutunan nyo sa akin
11:08.0
Pag nagde-debate kayo sa mga kaibigan nyo
11:11.0
Ah, gawin nyo akong reference
11:12.0
Ma, okay na okay na sa akin yun, di ba?
11:15.0
So, dun palang masaya na ako, mga kamates, mga kaibigan
11:18.0
Pero si Maruko, nakita ko kasi
11:20.0
Ah, I think nung isang araw
11:22.0
Hindi yata na siya member
11:23.0
So, nag-member ulit siya ngayon
11:25.0
Maraming salamat, Maruko
11:27.0
And promise ko sa inyo
11:28.0
Hindi natataas yung ano natin
11:30.0
Membership natin would remain forever
11:33.0
Na less than 80 pesos, di ba?
11:35.0
So, maraming salamat po
11:37.0
Malaking tulong yan sa channel
11:44.0
So, balik tayo dito
11:45.0
So, tingnan natin
11:51.0
So, nakukuha nyo ba yun?
11:54.0
Ang hindi ko lang kasi gusto dito
11:56.0
Madali kasing gumamit ng gender card
11:59.0
Kapag hindi nila gusto yung argumento mo
12:03.0
Kasi si Ato naman is coming from the streets of the Philippines
12:07.0
Na, one thing na, ito na
12:10.0
Sabihin ko na sa inyo, Nico Fuliente
12:12.0
Kaya, ko dinidiscuss to
12:14.0
Kasi nga, in the Philippines, our
12:16.0
We are lowest ranking po tayo
12:19.0
Sa science, sa math and science
12:21.0
So, I am in the understanding
12:24.0
Na pagdating sa definitions
12:27.0
Pagdating sa mga ganito
12:30.0
Madali tayong maniwala
12:32.0
Sa nakikita natin sa internet
12:34.0
Without even researching it
12:36.0
Or without even thinking it through
12:39.0
Without even thinking of what are the trends
12:42.0
The current trends or the current
12:44.0
The current understanding of our
12:55.0
Kung ano yung sinasabi niya dito
12:58.0
So, madali tayong mauto ng mga influencers
13:00.0
Especially yung mga malalaki influencers
13:03.0
Especially if maraming views
13:05.0
Maraming likes yung isang tao
13:07.0
Kasi basically doon lang
13:09.0
Ano yan eh, parang statistical yan eh
13:11.0
Statistical fallacy yun eh
13:13.0
Nakita mo na maraming nariniwala sa kanya
13:16.0
What he is probably saying is true
13:19.0
We have to look closer
13:21.0
And take a second look lage
13:22.0
Sa mga nakikita natin
13:24.0
So, ang sabi niya doon
13:26.0
Narinig niyo naman
13:27.0
He feels so attacked
13:31.0
Kinoll out ni Leah
13:37.0
Bakit ka nagsasalita about sa
13:40.0
Gender ng ibang babae
13:43.0
Kung hindi ka naman babae
13:45.0
So, I do think na of course
13:47.0
It's ridiculous if you are
13:49.0
If you have a liberal take on the matter
13:53.0
If you are going to be literal about it
13:56.0
If you are going to read
13:59.0
Not in between the lines
14:01.0
Yung tinitignan mo lang sya
14:03.0
Using your common sense
14:05.0
Kung bagay yung mababang pag-iisip lang
14:08.0
Pero it's still a valid question
14:11.0
Pwede mong itanong yun
14:12.0
There are no stupid questions in life
14:16.0
Hahanapin mo lang yung sagot
14:18.0
Meron mga dito sa Pilipinas
14:20.0
So, hindi pa tayo ready
14:21.0
Sa mga ganyang ideology
14:23.0
Nakakalito pa yan
14:26.0
So, feeling attacked daw sya
14:27.0
Kasi nga he is part of the minority
14:29.0
Now, let me ask you
14:31.0
If you are part of the minority
14:36.0
How are you different now
14:38.0
From people with disabilities
14:43.0
Yung mga indigenous people
14:47.0
Malayo sila sa kabihasnan
15:00.0
Kunyari, yung mga nasa Rice Terraces
15:03.0
Yung mga nasa Cordillera
15:06.0
Yung mga nasa bundok pa rin sila hanggang ngayon
15:09.0
So, how are you different from these minority groups
15:12.0
These ethnic groups
15:13.0
How are you different from that?
15:15.0
You have the choice
15:17.0
Na gawin yung gusto mo
15:19.0
Pero sila, they don't really have a choice
15:22.0
Ikaw, if you don't talk
15:26.0
Kunyari, hindi ka namin kilala
15:29.0
We could mistake you for a man
15:32.0
Pag tinignan mo sya, baka sya lalaki
15:34.0
I mean, titignan ko sya
15:35.0
So, how are you now part of the minority group
15:38.0
If that is the case?
15:40.0
So, ang point kasi nitong usapin na to
15:43.0
Is I am gearing towards
15:45.0
Yung gender roles and gender ideology na yan
15:49.0
It is all construct lang sya ng society natin
15:53.0
Ibig sabihin, it's an illusion
15:56.0
Or at least malang
15:57.0
There are groups of people who is pushing an agenda
16:02.0
That's why I'm going to introduce sa inyo
16:04.0
Influencers like Matt Walsh
16:06.0
At saka yung kanyang movie
16:10.0
Kasi, I don't want in my country
16:13.0
Mga kamates, mga kaibigan
16:15.0
Ayoko po na ang mangyari dito
16:17.0
Ay magkalito-lito tayo
16:19.0
Kung ano ba talaga
16:20.0
Ano ba ibig sabihin
16:22.0
Baka pag tinanong ko si Smoko sama
16:25.0
Kung ano yung babae
16:26.0
Pucha, malito na rin sya
16:27.0
Ngayon, mag tututunan natin yun
16:29.0
Pero dito kasi sa instance na to
16:31.0
Itong si Mr. Tito Mars
16:35.0
Ginagamit niya yung gender card na tinatawag
16:38.0
Nung kinol out siya ni Ato
16:43.0
Which is, you know, in a way
16:45.0
It's a valid question
16:46.0
Kasi nga, alam mo yun
16:48.0
Lahat naman tayo hindi sanay sa ganyan
16:51.0
Ha-dominant daw agad
16:53.0
Pero siya, pakinggan natin siya
16:55.0
Kailangan magsuot ng sexy
17:02.0
Kung sino pa talaga yung mga
17:04.0
Ah, edi ko rin magtutuloy
17:07.0
Si Liam kasi yun eh
17:08.0
Kasi nga pangit si Liam
17:09.0
Hindi naman gwapo si Liam
17:12.0
Ang i-imply niya doon
17:13.0
Kung sino pa yung pangit
17:14.0
O yung walang itura
17:15.0
Gano'n yung sinasabi
17:17.0
So, another form of ad hominem
17:19.0
Pag siya, yung tinanong
17:21.0
Nang something, well
17:22.0
It's a valid question
17:24.0
Bakit ka naki-human empowerment
17:26.0
If you are technically not part of it
17:29.0
Kasi, how can you contribute
17:31.0
An ideology to women
17:33.0
If you are not a woman yourself
17:35.0
It is a valid question
17:38.0
Kasi, pag sinabi mo
17:41.0
Ang ako, hindi ako pwedeng mag-contribute
17:43.0
Ng something about sa feminism
17:45.0
Kasi, hindi naman ako feminist
17:48.0
Mga kamates, mga kaibigan
17:50.0
Hindi ako, hindi ako nagsusubscribe
17:52.0
Doon sa ideology nila
17:57.0
And gender roles nowadays are
17:59.0
I think, a societal construct
18:02.0
Sa tingin ko, dito sa Pilipinas
18:04.0
Yung practicality of believing in gender roles
18:08.0
Kasi, nasa third world country tayo
18:10.0
I-insist mo pa ba
18:12.0
Na dapat ang nagtatrabaho lang lalaki
18:15.0
Kung wala ka na kayong makain
18:17.0
Kasi, yun yung gender roles dapat
18:22.0
Etong mga tinuturo nila ngayon sa inyo
18:26.0
At saka kay Tito Mars
18:28.0
Dapat high value man lang yung gusto mo
18:31.0
Tapos si Ato naman
18:32.0
Dapat may wife material ka
18:35.0
Bullshit yan pareo
18:37.0
Kasi, nasa third world country tayo
18:39.0
In the context of our country
18:41.0
That is not very good with science
18:46.0
Yung ating bilihin ay napakataas
18:50.0
At yung buhay natin ay napakahirap
18:52.0
Gender roles is supposed to be not an issue
18:56.0
Ang problema kasi mga kabataan ngayon
18:59.0
Yung mga 13, 14, 15
19:04.0
Yung mga 21 years old
19:08.0
Yung mga early gen siya
19:10.0
At saka yung mga bagong sibol ngayon
19:12.0
They are being indoctrinated
19:15.0
With this fucking western ideology of genders
19:20.0
This is why I'm really passionate about this
19:25.0
Pinanonod ko nung isang araw si Paulul
19:27.0
Parang yung leaning niya kasi is very liberal
19:32.0
Kasi nga yun yung gustong marinig ng batang ngayon
19:35.0
Na, yo, dapat lahat tayo
19:37.0
Empowerment, liberal shit, maraming genders
19:46.0
You are talking to Filipinos na mahina sila sa science
19:51.0
Siguro yung audience mo magagaling
19:54.0
Kasi mga middle class yan
19:56.0
I am not just aiming for the middle class
19:59.0
Mga kamates, mga kaibigan
20:00.0
I am aiming for everyone
20:02.0
The rich, the middle class and the poor
20:08.0
So, you get what I'm trying to say here
20:12.0
I am not just aiming for just one group of people
20:16.0
I am aiming for everyone who wants to listen to me
20:20.0
Exactly, they are being radicalized
20:22.0
Hindi ko gusto yun para dito sa ating bansa
20:25.0
This is why I am pushing for
20:28.0
Alam yun, matutunan muna natin yung basic
20:32.0
Bago tayo pumunta sa komplikado
20:34.0
Parang sa mathematics
20:35.0
Bago tayo magcalculus
20:37.0
Baka pwede muna mag-addition tayo
20:42.0
Yan, katulad ng Joshua Jet
20:44.0
On the other hand,
20:46.0
Without understanding of society nila
20:48.0
Kaya nga, kaya nga sinasabi ko sa iyo
20:50.0
Gender roles are bullshit, okay?
20:53.0
Especially in our country
20:55.0
Ang tinuturo ko dito is real equality
20:58.0
Ibig sabihin, pwede magtrabaho ang lalaki
21:00.0
Pwedeng magtrabaho ang babae
21:07.0
Meron lang, meron lang is
21:10.0
Ang meron lang dito is what you want
21:15.0
And of course, what you want
21:17.0
And what is possible
21:19.0
Maging kumunek na tayo sa realidad
21:22.0
For example, bibigan ko kayo
21:25.0
Kung bakit bullshit yung high value
21:27.0
High value na yan
21:28.0
Halimbawa, mayaman ako sobra
21:32.0
Ganon ako kayaman
21:34.0
Tapos 30 plus lang ako
21:37.0
Wala pa akong asawa
21:38.0
Naghanap ako ng asawa ko
21:40.0
Tapos meron isang babae
21:43.0
Na napakaganda niya
21:45.0
Let's say, isang 25 years old
21:50.0
Undergrad na nagtatrabaho sa Potato Corner
21:57.0
Tapos, nagustuhan ko yung babae na yun
22:01.0
So, in terms of your standard
22:04.0
This girl na napakaganda
22:06.0
Is not high value
22:08.0
Kasi Potato Corner lang siya nagwo work e
22:10.0
Minimum wage lang siya
22:13.0
High value man ako
22:14.0
Kasi Lucio Tan ako e
22:16.0
Malaki yung ano ko e
22:17.0
Malaki yung ano ko e
22:20.0
Yung aking network e
22:23.0
So, am I not able to fall in love with this woman
22:26.0
If I love her truly?
22:30.0
Where is this coming from?
22:34.0
Dapat gusto mo yung high value, low value
22:37.0
These are societal constructs
22:39.0
Na linalagyan mo sa table
22:42.0
If anything, you are objectifying people
22:44.0
Because you have this notion
22:46.0
That people should have value
22:53.0
Alam mo yun, kasi there is more to people
22:55.0
Than just what you see
22:56.0
Or what is defined as successful or not
22:59.0
Malay mo, yung babae na yun pala
23:05.0
Mabuting tao talaga siya
23:07.0
Talagang kapos lang sa opportunity sa buhay
23:10.0
So, who am I to judge this person?
23:15.0
Gender roles, mga kamates, mga kaibigan
23:19.0
Now, papakitaan ko kayo
23:25.0
Extreme idea of gender roles
23:29.0
Ano yung nagiging effect nito?
23:31.0
Alam ko, kilala nyo tong tao na to
23:34.0
Siguro kilala nyo si Da Flash
23:36.0
Di ba si Ezra Miller?
23:38.0
Kilala nyo yun, di ba yung ano
23:41.0
Now, this is his arrest
23:45.0
Tapos, kasi may ginawa siya
23:48.0
Tignan nyo how the gender card
23:50.0
Is being used here
23:51.0
Mga kamates, mga kaibigan
23:53.0
I'm not transgender, non-binary
23:54.0
I don't want to be searched by a man
23:56.0
I'm transgender, non-binary
23:57.0
And I don't want to be searched by a man
23:59.0
I claim my 4th Amendment rights
24:01.0
No, no, no, no, no
24:02.0
I got assaulted and I started filming
24:04.0
Let's talk stories outside
24:05.0
Let's talk stories outside
24:07.0
Isipin nyo, meron tayong magiging
24:09.0
Kung pinush natin yung gender ideology na yan dito
24:14.0
Yung gender roles na yan dito
24:16.0
That there are so many genders
24:18.0
Na dapat ang magsaserve sa'yo
24:20.0
Magsaserve sa'yo ng arrest mo
24:22.0
Is a police officer na same gender sa'yo
24:25.0
You know how difficult it is dito sa Pilipinas?
24:29.0
That is why I am very disappointed ngayon
24:32.0
Sa influencer space
24:33.0
Kasi they're not talking about the real
24:36.0
What is happening dito sa bansa natin
24:39.0
Hindi nila sinasabi sa inyo
24:43.0
Hindi nila binibigyan ng awareness yung mga tao
24:48.0
You can love anyone you want
24:52.0
Sa pamilya ngayon
24:54.0
It's better to have more than one source of income
24:56.0
If the mom and the dad can work
25:03.0
Parang kailangan kasi dapat may wife potential
25:07.0
No, love who you want
25:08.0
This is what I preach
25:16.0
Gender role comes all the way to our primal instinct
25:18.0
Yeah, I understand that
25:21.0
We are not in that kind of society
25:23.0
Naintindihan mo ba?
25:25.0
Jobs are made so that it is doable by men and women
25:30.0
Sure, there are jobs that are
25:35.0
Mas okay sa lalake, mas okay sa babae
25:37.0
Pero the thing is
25:39.0
Society is constructed in such a way that
25:41.0
Both men and women can have equal opportunity
25:45.0
So kita nyo, kita nyo yung ginawa nito ha
26:01.0
I'm being arrested for disorderly conduct?
26:04.0
Okay, I was assaulted
26:07.0
No, you're not supposed to be
26:08.0
I claim my 9th amendment rights to not be
26:11.0
disorderly conduct being seized on no probable cause
26:15.0
That you will not be able to offer in a court of law
26:18.0
I claim my 4th amendment rights to not be
26:20.0
Not be searched by
26:22.0
I'm transgender and I'm binary and I don't want to be searched by a man
26:25.0
I claim my 4th amendment rights
26:28.0
Just in case you worry that they're bullets
26:29.0
Those are nerf bullets
26:30.0
They're fake and they're a toy
26:32.0
That's my Cellbuckle and my nerf bullets
26:34.0
I appreciate that
26:36.0
Na narinig nyo iyon
26:37.0
So parang sinasabi niya dito na
26:41.0
I'm transgender and I'm binary
26:43.0
Ganon kala layong gender identity
26:49.0
Yung gender debate culture sa Amerika
26:52.0
It's such a messy messy
26:56.0
Part ng society nila
26:58.0
That I don't want us
27:00.0
Sa society natin to experience
27:03.0
Yun yung iniiwasan ko
27:04.0
Let's focus on the basic first
27:08.0
Pagka alam na alam natin
27:10.0
Maalam na tayo dyan
27:11.0
Let's then talk about it
27:13.0
Right now I can see that we're not ready for it
27:16.0
Because I see that
27:17.0
People like Ato and Tito Mars
27:19.0
Is the only people talking about it
27:22.0
In the public sense
27:23.0
Not our legislators
27:25.0
Yung mga legislators natin busy
27:27.0
Na magayos ng road rage incident
27:30.0
Na dapat MMDA yung gumagawa
27:32.0
But not about the gender of people
27:35.0
Ang gender of people
27:36.0
Ang nag-uusap dyan mga tambay
27:38.0
Mga tambay sa internet na
27:40.0
Nagbebenta ng merch
27:42.0
O kaya nagbebenta ng slimming pills
27:44.0
Na hindi naman nakakapayat
27:47.0
So it's very frustrating for me
27:50.0
So now mga kamates
27:53.0
And hindi ko na ipiplay siguro
27:56.0
Yung kay Tito Mars
27:57.0
Kasi wala namang kwenta
27:59.0
Eto kasi yung dapat ipiplay ko
28:01.0
And 30 minutes tong video na to
28:04.0
Pero yung opinion nya is 8 minutes only
28:07.0
And it's talking about
28:11.0
Na nagtuturo ng gender roles
28:17.0
Na hindi naman sya nanay
28:18.0
Siguro nakita nyo yung nanay nya
28:21.0
I don't know his credibility
28:24.0
To talk about gender roles
28:30.0
How to discuss science in public
28:32.0
Kasi nga naging teacher ako
28:37.0
I don't know why he's teaching
28:40.0
Women na gustong magka-anak
28:43.0
At saka mga nanay
28:45.0
I don't understand why he is the
28:48.0
The consensus expert
28:51.0
Pagdating sa field na yun
28:56.0
Yung pagtuturo ng pagiging nanay
28:58.0
Siguro sa mga doktor
29:00.0
Ano ba ang tawag doon?
29:02.0
Or mga pediatrician
29:04.0
Siguro sila yung dapat natin
29:06.0
Maging source of information doon
29:08.0
Not another dude sa internet
29:13.0
So I will skip this part
29:15.0
And I will introduce sa inyo
29:16.0
Mga kamates, mga kaibigan
29:17.0
Yung special guest natin
29:19.0
Si Mr. Matt Walsh
29:26.0
Aaminin ko na sa'yo
29:29.0
Sa inyo mga kamates, mga kaibigan
29:31.0
Si Mr. Matt Walsh
29:33.0
Ay isang conservative na
29:36.0
Yung political leaning niya
29:40.0
Si Ezra Miller kasi
29:41.0
Ang leaning niya is
29:44.0
So ang mga liberals
29:48.0
Mas open sila sa gender debate
29:51.0
Kumbaga ang stand nila dito
29:52.0
There are many many genders
29:57.0
Ang definition natin
29:59.0
You can already define genders
30:02.0
Dito sa mga liberals
30:04.0
You can not define gender
30:08.0
Si Matt Walsh naman
30:09.0
Also shares my sentiment
30:12.0
So medyo conservative yung
30:13.0
Sentiment ko pagdating dito
30:18.0
I believe that dapat
30:19.0
Meron tayong exact measurement
30:21.0
Of gender at birth
30:25.0
Meron siyang ginawang movie called
30:31.0
Is exactly what it's
30:40.0
Ngayon sa Amerika
30:41.0
They have a problem
30:42.0
Defining what is a woman
30:51.0
Eto ba dinibank na to ni Paulo
30:53.0
Itong movie na to?
30:58.0
I do want this movie
31:00.0
Kasi I'm showing you
31:01.0
The problem of America right now
31:10.0
To be more politically correct
31:13.0
So they cannot define anymore
31:16.0
Kasi nga pag tinanong mo sila
31:18.0
Iba iba yung isasagot nila
31:20.0
And meron mga influencers do
31:26.0
Definition ng women
31:28.0
I would like to give you
31:29.0
A snippet of this movie
31:33.0
May mga mods ba tayo dito?
31:35.0
Siguro pwede natin itong ilagay sa
31:40.0
CGI Camatis Group
31:41.0
Para mapanood nyong lahat
31:43.0
This is a very good movie to watch
31:45.0
To show you the problem of gender
31:48.0
That I do not wish on this country
31:55.0
Ohoy! Hello sa inyo
32:05.0
What is your gender?
32:07.0
Of course hindi tayo gano'n
32:09.0
Sa realidad ng buhay
32:20.0
Medyo para ma-forward ko lang ng konti
32:22.0
Kasi napanood ko na to
32:23.0
Si John Money is the one
32:25.0
Who introduced gender ideology
32:27.0
He is the father of
32:29.0
This gender identity
32:35.0
Hindi naman father
32:36.0
Siguro proponent of it
32:38.0
To make it mainstream
32:40.0
People are adapting
32:41.0
This person's ideology
32:43.0
Yung mga ideology nila
32:47.0
Yung mga LGBT movement
32:49.0
You can trace it down sa kanya
32:52.0
So panoorin na lang natin mamaya yan
32:55.0
Isyashare namin to
32:56.0
Doon sa CGI Camatis Group
33:02.0
See actually si Comixman
33:03.0
Yung nagbigay sakin ito
33:04.0
And I was really hooked on it
33:05.0
And then I saw the problem
33:06.0
Dito sa Pilipinas
33:08.0
Hindi naman nila siguro
33:13.0
Is being echoed here
33:15.0
It is a serious problem
33:20.0
Ang nakikita lang natin
33:21.0
Yung mga nag-aaway
33:22.0
Sa putang inang kalsada
33:24.0
That's not the problem here
33:26.0
John Money was a psychiatrist
33:28.0
Environment determined
33:30.0
Could be raised as a girl
33:34.0
And so Money tried out his theory
33:36.0
On two young twin boys
33:38.0
When the twins were 8 months old
33:41.0
And they went to be circumcised
33:45.0
Paano kita yakit?
33:46.0
Eh wala nga akong stream yard boy
33:49.0
Whose name was Bruce
33:50.0
At saka patapos na ako bro
33:51.0
Papanood ko ito sa mga followers natin
33:55.0
Para makita nila yung problema
33:57.0
Sa Amerika ngayon
33:59.0
Something went wrong with the
34:03.0
And his penis was burnt off
34:05.0
They stopped and didn't do
34:06.0
A second circumcision
34:07.0
On the other twin
34:08.0
As you might imagine
34:09.0
And the parents of course
34:11.0
Didn't know what to do
34:12.0
So explain ko lang
34:13.0
Yung nangyari sa kanila
34:15.0
Kasi uso kasi dun yung tuli
34:22.0
Na medyo na damage
34:24.0
Yung kanyang tek-tek
34:26.0
Yung penis nya na damage
34:28.0
So ang ginawa nung parents
34:29.0
Since na damage yung
34:33.0
Pinatanggal na lang
34:34.0
Tapos ginawa siyang babae
34:38.0
Miski kasi ibahin mo
34:39.0
Yung itsura ng iyong
34:43.0
Yung iyong hormones
34:45.0
Ay hindi magbabago
34:48.0
Hormones is a very different function
34:55.0
Forward ko lang ng konti ha
34:58.0
Medyo gruesome to eh
35:02.0
Ito yung lalaki na yun
35:03.0
Yung tinutukoy natin
35:04.0
Hindi pa rin siya
35:08.0
Hindi talaga siya
35:09.0
Hindi niya talaga
35:14.0
Ang nangyari sa kanya
35:15.0
Since pinilit sa kanya
35:16.0
Ng parents na yun
35:17.0
Yung perspective na yun
35:20.0
Na fuck up siya pag laki
35:22.0
Now I'm not gonna tell you
35:23.0
Kung ano yung nangyari sa kanya
35:25.0
I think its better
35:26.0
Na panoorin nyo to
35:29.0
And we will end there
35:32.0
So iiwan ko po yung link dito
35:35.0
Ipin pin ko dito sa aking channel
35:38.0
Para lang meron kayong panoorin
35:41.0
And kung mamaya naman
35:42.0
Kung hindi nyo naman makita yung link dito
35:46.0
CGI Kamatis group yan
35:48.0
Sa ating Facebook page
35:49.0
Sa ating Facebook groups
35:51.0
Yun lang naman yung sa akin for today
35:56.0
Mega love shoutouts
35:57.0
Sa mga admin natin
35:59.0
At saka si Kevin Mars
36:00.0
Na laging nandito
36:02.0
At kay Kiris Bacolay
