PART 2: SOPLA KAY BITAG AT BATAS! TIGAS ULONG RESORT OWNER SA ANDA, BOHOL!
00:27.0
Wala akong paglabag.
00:28.2
You're now saying there is no violation.
00:30.4
Walang violation.
00:31.2
Yung lupa na tinuyuan ng ARCO
00:32.9
ay aking lupa, yun.
00:36.4
Sino ang nagsabing wala kang paglabag?
00:38.5
Binigyan ka na enough notices.
00:41.2
Hindi doon sa sinasabing negosyo mo,
00:43.6
kundi doon sa ARCO.
00:45.9
That's an illegal structure.
00:47.7
You see that violation?
00:48.7
Notice of illegal construction.
00:51.9
Do you have the proof that I have violated that?
00:55.1
Bakit mo sinasabing wala kang paglabag?
01:01.8
Maliwanag po kasi.
01:03.3
Illegal construction without permit.
01:06.6
May parusang pagkabilanggo po yan.
01:08.8
Tatlong taon o mahigit pa.
01:11.2
At paglabag po yan sa National Building Code,
01:14.1
Section 301, Presidential Decree 1096.
01:20.6
Ano bang gusto mo?
01:21.3
I-demolish yung ano mo?
01:22.5
O ikaw man i-demolish?
01:23.5
I don't know right now.
01:24.6
I cannot answer you right now.
01:26.3
Ba't ang tigas ng ulo mo na ayaw mo tanggalin yan?
01:28.2
Ano mawawala sa iyo?
01:29.5
Magbabawasan ko paggagwapong lalaki?
01:31.2
Baga ko tumingin sa bakuran ng iba,
01:33.4
tumingin ka muna sa bakuran mo.
01:34.6
May problema nga.
01:39.0
bilang balanse pagbigay po
01:42.0
marinig po ang paliwanag nitong si Abdon de la Peña
01:44.8
na nagbiyahi pa mula buhol
01:46.7
para lang dito po live makarating sa atin.
01:49.9
Pakikinggan po natin siya.
01:51.1
Kasama po natin live sa studio,
01:52.9
si Abdon de la Peña.
01:54.1
Magandang umaga sa iyo, Sir Abdon.
01:55.8
Magandang umaga din po.
01:59.1
siguro naman para lahat, ano?
02:00.9
Ako'y nagpapasalamat.
02:02.1
At nakita ko na pumunta ka rito,
02:05.6
bibigyan kita ng buong galang
02:07.4
na lahat ng karapatan mong marinig
02:09.8
at hindi kami nagtatabla rito.
02:11.9
Pero tanong ko lang sa iyo,
02:12.9
sige, mauna siguro,
02:14.1
anong masasabi mo rito?
02:15.9
I'm very much thankful
02:17.5
that you gave me this opportunity to be here.
02:20.3
Ang katotohanan po ay
02:21.5
video na pansin ko
02:24.8
na motivated itong
02:26.2
Barangay Kapitan,
02:30.3
Na hindi sa ill will, no?
02:32.9
But I think he's motivated of
02:35.4
or by some kind of pecuniary interest.
02:38.6
Kasi yung lupa ako,
02:41.8
without my permission
02:44.0
while I'm away in the United States.
02:47.4
Ngayon, yung lupa pala
02:48.4
adjacent sa kanya
02:52.0
if there was like
02:53.2
exploration or exploitation
02:55.6
or exercise of eminent domain,
02:58.2
by the power of the government,
02:59.7
dapat hati-hati kami.
03:02.0
Ang ginawa ngayon,
03:04.7
without my consent,
03:07.1
without my prior knowledge.
03:09.7
ang ginawa niya ngayon,
03:11.7
inunahan niya ako
03:13.7
na punta siya dito.
03:16.2
pumunta muna siya doon sa
03:20.2
The fact of the matter is that
03:22.2
hindi siya nakakuha ng
03:24.2
order sa munisipyo.
03:28.9
parang naprostated siya.
03:34.9
So, pumunta ako doon.
03:36.9
ang problema sa kanya,
03:37.9
hindi naman siya pumunta doon.
03:40.9
So, he was the complainant,
03:41.9
pero hindi siya pumunta doon
03:42.9
sa conference ng DNR.
03:45.9
how come that the complainant
03:48.9
when he was the one
03:49.9
who brought the action
03:52.9
Maganda yung paliwanag mo,
03:53.9
pero bago ang lahat,
03:58.9
Let's go look at the
03:59.9
root of the problem.
04:01.9
the effect of the problem.
04:04.9
Pag imbalansi ako rito,
04:06.9
bilang an investigative journalist,
04:09.9
this is a family feud,
04:10.9
this is a family problem.
04:14.9
gusto mong sabihin,
04:18.9
kasi hindi kayo nagkasundo.
04:22.9
sa issue ng pamilya.
04:25.9
Kasi may korte diyan.
04:27.9
I-center natin dito
04:35.9
You're now saying
04:36.9
there is no violation.
04:37.9
Walang violation.
04:38.9
Yung lupa na tinayuan ng ARCO
04:39.9
ay aking lupa yun.
04:43.9
during September,
04:44.9
before I left to America,
04:48.9
ng barangay clearance
04:49.9
so that I can obtain
04:50.9
a business permit.
04:55.9
predecessor niya,
04:57.9
sa January na lang
04:58.9
kasi para buo ang bayaran.
05:01.9
the barangay election.
05:02.9
So, when the election comes in,
05:03.9
siya ngayon ang nanalo.
05:08.9
Ngayong nananalo na siya,
05:09.9
sinabi niya ngayon na
05:12.9
ang aking assistant
05:14.9
barangay clearance
05:15.9
for business permit
05:17.9
sabi niya hindi raw
05:19.9
sa barangay daw yung
05:23.9
Which is not true.
05:29.9
while I was away,
05:30.9
I think 20 or 30 years ago,
05:32.9
sila ang nag-operate yan.
05:34.9
Yung cottages nila,
05:35.9
naglagay silang cottages
05:39.9
magbakas yun ako,
05:42.9
kasi gusto ko makatulong
05:43.9
doon sa barangay.
05:45.9
As a matter of fact,
05:50.9
para doon sa barangay.
05:52.9
ang dami ng barangay kapitan
05:55.9
ang kapitan ng...
05:57.9
I have to cut you down
05:58.9
because you are not going
06:00.9
I am now trying to find...
06:01.9
No, I'm not going
06:03.9
but I'm going to trace
06:04.9
the roots of the problem.
06:05.9
Hindi niya ako binigyan
06:07.9
ng barangay clearance
06:08.9
kasi sinabi niya doon
06:12.9
si Don de la Piña.
06:13.9
And you know why?
06:15.9
personal interest
06:17.9
with my business interest.
06:19.9
Meron siyang existing
06:20.9
na traveler's inn.
06:22.9
So, kung bibigyan niya ako
06:23.9
ng barangay permit,
06:24.9
it will be a competition.
06:26.9
So, yung cottages
06:27.9
na nilagay ko diyan,
06:35.9
there is what they call
06:37.9
Wala akong binawal doon
06:38.9
na dumadaan sila doon.
06:39.9
Kung gusto may mag-rent doon
06:40.9
sa aking cottages,
06:42.9
Sinabi mo kanina,
06:43.9
wala kang paglabag na nagawa.
06:46.9
Wala akong paglabag.
06:47.9
Sa alam ko, wala.
06:48.9
Sino ang nagsabing
06:49.9
wala kang paglabag?
06:50.9
Ang mga violations
06:51.9
ay nanggaling sa City Hall.
06:52.9
That's the local government.
06:57.9
hindi doon sa sinasabing negosyo mo,
06:59.9
kundi doon sa ARCO.
07:02.9
That's an illegal structure.
07:04.9
You see that violation?
07:05.9
Notice of illegal construction?
07:06.9
Now, that is from the office
07:08.9
of the City Hall.
07:09.9
If you've been in the United States,
07:11.9
you know exactly what City Hall
07:14.9
Dahil sa City Hall,
07:17.9
Barangay is just the lowest form.
07:20.9
wala kang paglabag.
07:21.9
Bakit mo sinasabing wala kang paglabag?
07:23.9
Eh ang nilabag mo ay ordinansa.
07:28.9
who makes the ordinance?
07:29.9
Hindi ba ang konseho?
07:32.9
It's headed by the vice mayor,
07:35.9
Once the ordinance becomes an ordinance,
07:36.9
it becomes a law.
07:39.9
did you just violate the law
07:40.9
na sinasabi ng City Hall?
07:42.9
Through the sanggunian,
07:43.9
enough notices was given to you.
07:45.9
Binigyan ka ng lahat ng pagkakataon.
07:48.9
Please do not cut me
07:49.9
because I will give you time.
07:51.9
Do not cut my thought.
07:54.9
I will not allow you.
07:55.9
Alright. Go ahead.
07:56.9
My throwing of thoughts is for importance.
07:58.9
So, sinasabi ng City Hall,
07:59.9
City Engineering,
08:00.9
wala na akong pakialam sa inyong magpipinsan.
08:04.9
and nobody's above the law.
08:06.9
We're talking about City Ordinance.
08:08.9
You just violated the City Ordinance.
08:10.9
Illegal yung struktura ng arko mo.
08:12.9
I am not after yung inyong feud ng kasin mo
08:15.9
because if you're saying he's motivated,
08:17.9
maybe you're right.
08:20.9
Pakita natin yung arko.
08:22.9
Ito ang inarereklamo.
08:23.9
You see that arc?
08:25.9
That structure of arc,
08:27.9
you should demolish that first.
08:29.9
The City Hall is already trying to tell you
08:31.9
that is an illegal structure
08:33.9
because you need,
08:34.9
kinakailangan mo ng business permit.
08:37.9
You cannot put that because,
08:39.9
let me tell you this,
08:42.9
ang nagsasabi City Hall, City Engineering,
08:44.9
you violated the Ordinance.
08:46.9
You're not above the law.
08:47.9
You don't belong to the City Council.
08:50.9
It's not intended.
08:51.9
That's an illegal structure.
08:52.9
So you're saying,
08:53.9
wala kang violation.
08:54.9
That's a violation.
08:55.9
Glaring violation.
08:56.9
Nilabag mo yung sinasabing City Ordinance.
08:58.9
Enough due process was given to you
09:01.9
so you will have to demolish that structure.
09:05.9
Personal demolition mo.
09:09.9
You're cutting me off.
09:12.9
You violated that.
09:13.9
And because you violated that,
09:14.9
that is unlawful.
09:16.9
Anong sagot mo sa City Hall?
09:18.9
Anong sagot mo sa City Council?
09:19.9
Anong sagot mo sa City Mayor?
09:20.9
Forget about your cousin na barangay.
09:22.9
Wala na akong pakialam doon.
09:26.9
Now, ang sagot ng barangay...
09:29.9
No, City Hall ang municipal.
09:30.9
Wala na akong pakialam sa barangay.
09:32.9
Ang sagot ng municipal hall,
09:34.9
hindi sila magbibigay ng business permit
09:36.9
unless niligay sa barangay clearance.
09:39.9
Structure pinag...
09:40.9
I don't care about your business permit.
09:42.9
Sandali muna, sandali.
09:48.9
I understand that, sir.
09:50.9
I'm referring to that.
09:51.9
Sandali, sandali.
09:53.9
And then papasalitin ka.
09:54.9
That structure there.
09:56.9
Yung arco mo, they declare that illegal.
09:58.9
So, you're still saying na wala kang nilabag na violation
10:01.9
yung structure naman, illegal.
10:03.9
Anong mawawala sa...
10:04.9
Hindi ka mababawasan paggagwapong lalaki mo,
10:06.9
umistiso ka man...
10:07.9
Mas gwapo ka, sir.
10:08.9
Kung tanggalin mo yung arco mo yan.
10:09.9
Kasi sagabal yan.
10:12.9
Tanggalin mo yan.
10:13.9
Sinasabi na si City Hall.
10:14.9
Ako naman, nagsasabi sa iyo, may paglabag ka.
10:16.9
Ba't ang tigas ng ulo mo na ayaw mo tanggalin yan?
10:18.9
Anong mawawala sa iyo?
10:19.9
Mababawasan ka paggagwapong lalaki?
10:21.9
Mas gwapo ka, sir.
10:22.9
O hindi mas gwapo ako.
10:23.9
Ako, kung ako nasa puder mo, tatanggalin ko yan.
10:26.9
Sir, let's clarify this matter.
10:28.9
No, you violated the City Ordinance.
10:30.9
Assuming there is a violation.
10:33.9
I'm not operating in the presumption.
10:35.9
I'm not operating in the assumption.
10:37.9
I'm operating in the legality.
10:40.9
The LGU has no jurisdiction to...
10:42.9
Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
10:46.9
...to give an order.
10:47.9
I was waiting for an order by the DNR.
10:49.9
Tawagan mo nga ang DNR.
10:50.9
Tawagan mo si Batas Mauricio.
10:53.9
I'm not supposed to be doing this to you with all honesty.
10:56.9
Sir, I am waiting for the order.
10:58.9
Ikaw mismo nagsabi, sir, na you have to get a court order.
11:02.9
I'm waiting for that court order to be delivered to my home.
11:09.9
But walang court order.
11:10.9
Ang ginawa nila, puro lang maritis sila, sir.
11:13.9
Nagmamaritis sila, ako sa...
11:16.9
Pagkakusahan mo ang city hall, the city council,
11:18.9
and the whole municipal hall officials, local government
11:28.9
Here, sasabihin ko na talagang totoo, sir.
11:30.9
They are protecting a big politician.
11:31.9
And this politician owns the Bungnaw CA, yung beach resort.
11:36.9
Hindi ko na sasabihin sana ito.
11:38.9
Own the big, big beach resort doon sa kaliwa.
11:41.9
Yung lupa na yan na dati nung basta pa kami.
11:44.9
Makakatawid kami doon.
11:45.9
makatawid kami doon, makatingin sa dagat,
11:48.1
kinukural na ngayon yan, nilagyan ng
11:50.0
cottages. That is an implied
11:52.1
ismin. That forms part of the
11:54.0
government property. Ngayon, yung mga
11:55.8
fishermen doon, hindi na sila makapunta
11:58.0
ng makalagay ng kanilang mga
12:00.8
pinapinsana nila.
12:03.7
Dapat yun ang lugar talaga ng mga
12:05.9
fishermen. Hindi yung low
12:07.2
pa ako na kung pupuntahan. Pero
12:09.8
just in case there is a typhoon,
12:11.8
I can offer my land. I can offer
12:13.8
my property para ma-accumulate lang
12:15.7
sila. Pero sa totoo lang, hindi ko
12:17.6
siya nasasabihin ito kasi tumawag sila
12:19.6
sa akin na... Mas maganda nga siguro, sabihin mo na lang
12:21.6
para malaman ng taong bahay. Kaya pata ni Juan de la Cruz
12:23.9
mamalaman ng... Huwag ka na magtagaw
12:25.8
sa akin. Okay. Si Mayor Totor, sir.
12:27.8
Sino si Mayor Totor? Mayor Totor, yung
12:29.5
neighboring na mayor namin sa
12:31.5
Kadihay. Anong gusto mo sabihin? Si Mayor Totor, parang
12:33.8
nag-land grabbing? Is that what it is?
12:36.1
I'm not putting words into your mouth
12:37.6
but apparently, papunta ka doon. Hindi ko
12:39.4
masasabing kasi that will be an acquisition.
12:42.0
Kaya nga. That is, that will
12:43.7
be an actionable... You're just basically...
12:45.3
Irakusahan mo na. Okay.
12:47.8
Let's go back. Do you
12:49.3
now accept that the city ordinance
12:51.7
in violation ka na, na pinatatanggal
12:53.7
siya yung ARCO, nag-uusap ng
12:55.2
council or the city council or municipal council
12:57.6
if you say so, with the mayor
12:59.7
there, sa mga sangguni, and you're given a
13:01.7
due... Let me finish.
13:03.6
I'm not here to debate with you.
13:06.1
You want debate? You can debate some other
13:07.6
people, not with me.
13:09.7
You know, in this show, I can
13:11.7
debate with you but I will not debate with you because
13:13.6
you're my guest. Thank you.
13:15.3
Earthly, you're my guest. I'll give you the
13:17.4
courtesy because I will have to
13:19.4
give you the right to be heard.
13:21.5
Here's the question. Thank you.
13:24.0
You said a while ago na wala
13:27.6
Pagtatayo ng ARCO. I will not
13:29.4
be involved doon sa kasin mo,
13:31.2
motivated, family food. I'm gonna
13:33.4
get out of there. So ako, diretsyo
13:35.5
ako. Itong ARCO. Palakihin muna
13:37.4
ito. Itong ARCO. ARCO,
13:39.6
ARCO. Yan. That is
13:41.4
the question. I'm not after
13:43.6
yung mga kubulmuro nila.
13:45.3
Gagay mo dyan. That's not the question.
13:47.6
I'm not questioning your property
13:49.6
doon sa sinasabing sa iyo
13:51.5
kung may tito lang ka o wala.
13:53.2
That ARCO is the question. The city
13:55.6
or municipal hall saying,
13:57.9
tanggalin mo yan.
13:59.4
Kasi yung structure na yan, sandali muna,
14:01.4
yung structure na yan, it needs a permit.
14:04.2
Yung structure na yan, illegal
14:05.3
structure says the city hall, says
14:07.4
the municipal council, says the sanggunian.
14:10.4
They've given you due
14:13.4
December, January, up to
14:15.3
now, enough due process.
14:17.5
How come you're still stubborn
14:19.4
and defying the city hall
14:21.5
na parang sabi mo tama ka,
14:23.4
you're now telling me and bringing me
14:25.2
kung sino-sino involved. I love to
14:27.2
listen to all the other politicians
14:29.5
but this time, what are we
14:31.4
gonna do dito sa ARCO na ito na sinasabing
14:33.6
illegal structure? Do you have
14:35.2
the proof that I have violated that?
14:37.3
Okay. Ano bang sabi ko sa iyo?
14:39.0
The city council says, at yung sanggunian,
14:41.5
binigyan ka ng due process, says
14:43.0
illegal construction. There was no order
14:45.2
from the... What do you call that?
14:47.0
Meron ka, Abdon de la Peña, oh.
14:48.5
Okay, sandali muna. That is only a notice, sir.
14:50.8
Sandali muna. That's not an order.
14:52.3
Well, now it's telling you to well demolish.
14:55.5
That's a notice of violation.
14:56.9
It's only an order, sir. Wala kang order.
14:59.0
You know what? You have to get the order from the
15:01.3
ARCO. You are now... Court.
15:03.1
You have the appetite to debate with me, but
15:05.1
I'm not gonna debate with you. I'm just telling you the truth, sir.
15:07.0
No, your truth is still in question.
15:09.5
Attorney Batas Mauricio, magandang
15:11.3
umaga sa iyo. Magandang umaga po.
15:13.3
Ginawang bentul po. Magandang umaga po.
15:15.2
Sa mga sambayanang narito sa ibang bitag mo
15:17.2
ni bentul po. Ano ang nakikita mo,
15:19.5
Attorney Batas Mauricio? Tandaan,
15:21.5
buhol to, ha? Malaking question sa buhol.
15:23.4
Maraming mga... Maraming mga
15:25.1
pasaway. Matitigas ang ulo dyan. Medyo
15:27.2
may problema ata sa probinsya.
15:28.7
Tangunahin po kanyang invocation
15:30.8
of Article 3, Section 1,
15:34.0
due process of law,
15:35.6
eh, nakakontra po yan, eh.
15:37.1
Ano po yan? Yung pinatawag nating
15:40.1
regalian doctrine.
15:42.8
Sa mga hindi pa po nakakadinig,
15:45.2
tawag na, regalian doctrine.
15:47.6
Sa ilalim ng 1987
15:50.6
1973 Constitution,
15:53.0
1935 Constitution,
15:55.2
ang sinasabi po dyan,
15:56.7
ang regalian doctrine.
15:58.3
Ang bansa, ang may-ari
16:00.5
ng lahat ng katubigan
16:04.9
at sa mga nakapaligid
16:06.9
sa Pilipinas. All lands of the
16:09.0
public domain, waters,
16:10.9
and all natural resources
16:12.8
are owned by the state.
16:15.2
Regalian doctrine.
16:16.8
Kung meron man pong dapat magreklamo dyan,
16:19.1
ginawang bentul po, Section 2,
16:23.0
of the Constitution, sinasabi,
16:25.5
walang karapatan ng sino man
16:26.8
tao dyan, sino man sa buong
16:29.0
Pilipinas, na magkaroon
16:31.4
ng titulo, magkaroon
16:33.1
ng tax declaration, magkaroon
16:35.3
ng kung ano-ano, pagpagsasabing
16:37.5
sila ang may-ari.
16:39.1
Bakit po? Mag-ari po ng estado
16:41.1
yan at hindi po pinapahintulutan
16:45.2
Yung mga ganyang uri, mga
16:46.6
foreshore lands, hindi po
16:48.8
pinapahintulutan yan, mapunta
16:50.8
sa mga pribadong may-ari.
16:52.4
Paano po magkakaroon ng titulo
16:54.4
ang mga pribadong tao sa mga beachfront?
16:58.1
Meron po isang kapraana,
16:59.5
iteklara ng Pangulo
17:00.7
na yung lupang yan, beachfront na yan,
17:03.7
eh pwede na pong kunin
17:05.3
ng mga pribadong tao.
17:08.0
So ang hahanapin po natin
17:09.4
sa ating mabunying panahon,
17:11.5
meron po ba kayong
17:13.0
presidential proclamation?
17:15.2
Yung po ang tanong sa kanya,
17:16.3
ginawang Ben Tulto, na nagsasabing
17:18.6
yung lupa mo na kinatatayuan mo
17:20.5
at nilagyan mo pa ng napakalaking argo,
17:23.7
ay po pwedeng maging
17:24.8
pag-aari ng pribadong tao.
17:27.1
Maganda po yan. Kasi po
17:28.8
pagka meron siyang sinasabing
17:30.8
gano'n, eh malulusutan niya to.
17:32.7
Pero pagka hindi, maliwanag po,
17:35.7
po pwede po siyang demandahin
17:37.1
ng gobyerno para siya
17:38.6
mapalis yan. At ang pagdidemanda
17:41.0
po kahit sinong pribadong tao,
17:43.3
napektado ng kanyang mga itinayong
17:45.1
struktura, pwede po
17:47.7
Okay. Well, tanong ni Atty. Batas
17:51.2
to wrap it all up. Meron ka bang
17:53.1
pinangahawakan presidential proclamation
17:55.4
na nagsasabit, eh, dineklara na yan
17:57.7
na pagiging private land,
18:00.5
Thank you very much to Atty. Mauricio
18:03.1
for the clarification. Right now,
18:06.3
for sure lease application.
18:09.8
Pending for sure lease application.
18:12.7
Malinaw, Atty. Batas.
18:13.9
So what do you think?
18:15.1
I'm going to be approved.
18:16.2
Pending application at maliwanag namang
18:18.9
hindi aprobado. Illegal po yung pagtatayo.
18:21.4
Exactly. The mundo!
18:23.1
Hindi pa yan naibigay sa'yo.
18:24.8
Alam ko naman yan kasi ang DNR siguro tatanga-tanga.
18:27.5
I'm sorry. Maraming tanga.
18:29.1
Kaya kuminsa, naisahan sila sa buhol.
18:31.1
Defend yourself. Presidential proclamation,
18:33.3
sabi mo, for sure,
18:35.1
hindi pa yung sa'yo yan. Wala pang nakikita
18:37.2
rito. Application ka pa lang. Kailan ka
18:39.1
nag-apply? Matagal na. Well, matagal ka
18:40.9
nag-apply. Ibig sabihin, well,
18:43.2
anong tingin mo doon, Atty? Matagal na nag-apply.
18:48.7
Hindi aprobado nga. It cannot be.
18:51.1
You can be a claimant.
18:52.7
Pwede ba niyang sabihin? Tax declaration.
18:59.0
Don't say speculation. A law is a law.
19:01.1
We're not here speculating. You're speculating.
19:03.4
We're not speculating.
19:04.4
Meron ako petition kasi may
19:06.8
notice of removal by the
19:10.8
I have a petition
19:12.3
for reconsideration
19:14.5
on the imposition of the
19:16.4
removal of the structure.
19:18.3
Meron ako petition.
19:19.9
Wala pang order ng
19:22.5
DNR yan. Matagal na po ba
19:24.8
kayo nasa ibang bansa?
19:27.4
Gaano po kayo katagal dito?
19:34.1
Are you a citizen? I am a dual citizen, sir.
19:36.6
Dual citizen. Okay. You're a dual citizen.
19:38.8
Yes, sir. Most of the time, sa states ka ba
19:40.8
nang-state? Yes, sir.
19:42.3
So that's the reason why you're acting this way?
19:44.5
Well, I'm a New Yorker, sir, just like you.
19:47.5
You know my attitude, like a New Yorker, too.
19:49.1
No, no, no. I'm not a New Yorker.
19:53.5
You are. I understand you are an American, sir.
19:56.1
No, no. I'm not an American.
19:58.0
Well, now, you know, you see this?
20:01.1
Your accent seems to be an American.
20:03.0
Now, you're judging me. Just because I talk like an American, maybe,
20:06.4
for you, hindi po.
20:08.0
I am not an American. I'm a very Filipino.
20:10.5
I'm proud to be a Filipino. But you're not
20:12.3
trying to tell me I'm an American. I am not an
20:14.4
American. You want to check it with the U.S. Embassy?
20:16.6
You want to check my Philippine passport?
20:20.4
You changed your accent, sir.
20:21.5
I was born in the Philippines, Lanao, Dansalan, Lanao.
20:25.1
O, Bisaya, eh, kasi...
20:26.0
Bisaya, maghihapon ko.
20:27.3
Pero ikaw, American, ka-duan.
20:30.4
Ganito na lang, nawawalan tayo.
20:32.7
Hanggat wala kang presidential
20:34.3
proclamation, tulad na sinasabi ng
20:36.1
attorney, may problema tayo.
20:37.9
Kasi, you're claiming the land.
20:40.4
You're still a claimant until such
20:42.2
time it's already given to you.
20:46.1
I'll talk to you more the American way.
20:48.4
Until such time you can produce a title or
20:50.5
presidential proclamation, I will respect
20:52.6
that. For now, follow the law.
20:55.0
Nobody's above the law.
20:56.3
The law applies to all or not at all.
20:58.3
You're still applying. You're still a claimant.
21:00.8
You're not an owner
21:02.1
of the piece of property.
21:04.2
That's still owned by the state.
21:08.4
Checkmate. Ano ang gagawin mo
21:11.5
Sir, I'm waiting for the order of day.
21:14.4
Can you have the, you know...
21:15.7
I'm sorry to tell you this.
21:18.5
I still have jurisdiction over that property, sir.
21:20.4
Why do you got the intestinal fortitude to trade it?
21:22.3
You own the land. As a matter of fact, you still don't.
21:25.1
No, the state owned the land.
21:27.0
I have the title.
21:28.1
You don't have the title.
21:30.6
You're still a claimant under presidential proclamation
21:33.3
subject to the approval.
21:34.6
Attorney Mauricio is invoking the
21:36.7
Regalian Doctrine.
21:37.8
I just want you to follow the law.
21:40.8
I'd just love to talk to you.
21:42.1
You are a kind of guy, good-looking,
21:44.4
and you can articulate your position.
21:48.4
And I can do, too.
21:49.8
Ganito na lang, boss.
21:51.3
Kasi maraming nanonood sa atin.
21:53.6
Ayaw ko kasing isipin nila
21:56.2
ang mga taga-buhol abusado.
21:58.7
Hindi naman, sir.
22:00.4
Mababait ang taga-buhol.
22:01.7
Kasi yung mga iba riyan.
22:03.1
Kasi isa ka doon.
22:04.3
Ang mga buhol, I love buhol.
22:06.3
Ang gusto ko lang sabihin sa'yo,
22:08.3
baka kasi dito sa ginagawa mo, may issue na sa buhol.
22:11.0
May issue na doon sa chocolate.
22:12.2
May issue na nga.
22:13.0
Maraming issue na.
22:14.4
Buhol sa ibang bansa.
22:15.7
Maraming mga politikong sangkot dito.
22:17.7
Alam ko yung mga land robbers.
22:19.1
I can smell them.
22:20.2
I know the color.
22:21.6
But the thing that I'm saying,
22:23.0
before you start looking at the backyard dividers,
22:25.3
look at your own backyard.
22:26.7
You violated the law.
22:28.0
Baga ko tumingin sa bakuran ng iba,
22:30.1
tumingin ka muna sa bakuran mo.
22:31.3
May problema nga.
22:32.2
Parang they violated the law,
22:33.8
so therefore, you should also have the right to violate.
22:36.3
Kung ito mga putok sa buho na ito
22:37.8
na mga politikong sinasabi mo,
22:39.6
putok sa buho ang tawag ko sa kanila,
22:40.9
sila yung sinasabi natin na pinagsasamantalahan
22:42.9
gamit ang kalangkapangyarihan.
22:45.0
Magiging derecho na ako rito.
22:46.8
Silang hinalal ng taong bayan
22:48.4
para pagsilbihan silang kumakamkam.
22:50.9
Is that what you want to hear?
22:52.2
Now, tell me who these people are
22:54.2
and I will give you exactly what you need.
22:57.4
Well, I'll tell you this.
22:58.4
All forms of abuse,
22:59.9
all forms of exploitation,
23:02.0
all forms of scheming and scamming,
23:04.0
all forms ng panluloko,
23:06.0
all forms of neglect,
23:07.4
abuse of authority,
23:08.7
sapul dito sa pitag yan.
23:09.7
Sir, I don't want to reiterate to you
23:11.2
the equal protection of the law.
23:12.9
Because I am being targeted.
23:14.5
And there are too many violators ahead of me.
23:17.2
I don't want to argue with that.
23:19.6
So, for the time meaning,
23:20.9
anong gagawin mo sa ARCO?
23:22.1
I have to wait for an order.
23:23.5
Gusto mong dalhin ko ito sa DNR sa Maine?
23:27.0
Well, gusto mong,
23:28.9
ang tigas ng ulo mo sa region pa lang
23:30.5
sinasabi na sa iyo eh.
23:31.8
Sa provincial pa lang
23:32.9
sinasabi na sa iyo eh.
23:34.1
So, meron na nga akong motion
23:35.2
for reconsideration?
23:36.0
Well, sa korte yan.
23:36.9
At in the meantime,
23:37.5
pag nagmo-motion ka,
23:38.9
hindi pinakikialaman.
23:40.2
Marami kaming nakikita sa iyo.
23:41.6
So, ARCO ang pinag-uusapan.
23:43.0
Itong ARCO na ito,
23:43.9
nakikipag-debate ka sa akin.
23:45.3
I'm in the forest state.
23:46.4
You are a respondent.
23:47.8
And I respect journalism.
23:52.0
anong gagawin mo sa ARCO?
23:53.3
I have to wait for an order, sir.
23:54.5
So, gusto mong sabihin,
23:56.2
tatanggalin mo lang
23:57.5
pag nakakuha ka na ng order.
23:59.0
Nandiyan pa ba si Atty. Patas Mauricio?
24:00.4
There will be a due process of law,
24:02.4
Maliwanag po kasi,
24:03.6
pagka po ang pinag-uusapan natin,
24:05.3
yung mga ganyang illegal na struktura,
24:07.3
kailangan pong basahin ni Inter-Denepenya.
24:09.8
Yung pong Section 301 ng PD 1096,
24:13.9
illegal construction without permit,
24:17.4
ginawang gantul po.
24:18.5
May parusang pagkakabilanggo po yan,
24:20.7
tatlong taon o mahigit pa.
24:23.1
At automatic po dapat ang decision dyan
24:27.9
gibayin yan kay gusto ni Mr. Delapeña o hindi.
24:32.2
Paglabag po yan sa National Building Code,
24:34.4
hindi ko lang po yung provision,
24:36.4
Section 301, Presidential Decree,
24:39.8
1096, ginawang gantul.
24:43.4
So dito, Atty., malino na po ang sinasabi natin.
24:46.7
Ako naman nagpapasalamat dito kay Mr. Delapeña.
24:49.4
Nagbiyahi pa siya rito, gusto niya tayo makakita.
24:51.4
Hindi naman ako nakikipagdebate sa kanya, Atty.
24:53.8
Ako naman, ano bang gusto mo?
24:55.7
Idedemolish yung ano mo?
24:56.9
O ikaw magdedemolish?
24:58.9
I don't know right now.
24:59.9
I cannot answer you right now.
25:01.6
Atty., may last word ka ba?
25:03.4
Kasi he's entitled to his opinion.
25:05.1
He wants, he can defy all he wants at the end of the day.
25:08.3
I want to see that the structure,
25:12.2
Dapat pong dibain na niya kasi para may panahon pa siyang makaiwa sa kasong kriminal.
25:17.3
Dahil kahit pa sino po na makakita niyan, makikita ng iligal,
25:22.1
bilikado po yan ang katayuan niya dahil pwede siyang idemanda.
25:25.6
Not necessarily city hall employees anymore.
25:28.1
Not necessarily office.
25:31.1
Taong bayan na po yan kung pwedeng magreklamo sa kanya.
25:34.9
In fact, maraming notices na ito.
25:36.7
Ang sabi niya, depense niya, hanggat wala namang order,
25:39.6
anything because notices are just notices.
25:41.6
What do you think?
25:42.1
Hindi po totoo yun.
25:43.1
Yun lang pong pagbibigay ng notisya na meron po siyang paglabag sa batas.
25:47.4
Yan po ay kautosan na sa kanya na kumilos at tanggalin yung paglabag na kanyang ginawa.
25:54.1
Tanggalin ang arpo na yan dahil hindi po yan pinahintulutan,
26:01.2
walang engineer's permit, walang building official permit.
26:05.0
At sa totoo lang, nakatayo po yan sa public property.
26:09.9
Atty., maraming salamat na inarticulate mo na yung law.
26:13.5
Can I have a last word, sir?
26:16.7
Atty., I have done my best effort to produce the license permit, barangay permit, barangay clearance,
26:24.9
but I was being blocked by the punong bayan, Amora.
26:29.4
So, what will I do?
26:31.1
And that property, that arpo there, it should be treated on my own land.
26:35.9
I comply with the law first.
26:39.6
Take the law first before you can even invoke the protection of the law.
26:44.3
Anyone who invokes the protection of the law must show obedience first.
26:49.3
Sabi nga po, binong de la Peña, he who comes to court must come with clean hands.
26:55.6
And that's why I'm willing to go to the court.
26:57.6
Because there's a violation.
26:59.3
May problema na po kayo dyan.
27:01.2
And I'm not supposed to be advising you.
27:03.3
We're just notifying you about the law, Mr. de la Peña.
27:07.1
Thank you very much, sir.
27:09.6
Okay, Mr. de la Peña, with due respect, pinigyan kita ng pagkakataon.
27:13.6
I may disagree with you, but, well, I disagree agreeably with you.
27:18.5
I disagree agreeably with you because I do not agree with you.
27:22.0
But you know what?
27:24.5
The law will take its course.
27:26.7
I will stand doon sa mga and make sure na yung arko mo niyan, ipapag-ibakoyan.
27:32.4
Because that's on behalf of the city ng munisipyo ninyo.
27:37.7
Dito sa parting to, narerespeto kita, I want to see that tore down, magkakatunggalin na tayo riyan.
27:44.3
Kasi tatayo na ako doon sa mga taong tuwayo.
27:46.2
At matandaan, elected official yung barangay.
27:49.0
And from that, lumapit sa amin.
27:51.1
Fourth estate ako.
27:52.4
But I will use available resources because in the fourth estate, because I see the infirmities, kasama ko sa infirmity.
27:59.4
Marami diyang magigiba, sir.
28:00.8
Well, well, so it starts with you.
28:03.4
You have to start from the first person who...
28:07.1
Who is called illegally.
28:09.6
Wala tayong papungpa.
28:10.2
Do it proportionately.
28:12.4
Please do not tell me...
28:14.3
Do not, do not tell me exactly what to do my job.
28:17.9
Because I know my job.
28:19.1
Do not seem to be a...
28:19.9
No, no, you're not right.
28:21.3
You just follow the law.
28:22.8
You're entitled to what you say.
28:24.7
Whatever the law says, I have to follow.
28:26.3
Anyway, I'm going to cut you off.
28:28.4
Para dito sa cut you off and then giving you the due respect and everything.
28:32.3
Alagi isang pampasang sumbungan.
28:34.2
Hindi po umatras kung sino pong tama.
28:36.1
Talagang itatama ko.
28:37.1
Tulong at serbisyo.
28:40.1
Hindi ko iiwan hanggat matibag po yan.
28:45.5
Mas kilala po ako si Bitag.
28:47.5
Apelido ko lang po yun eh.
28:49.1
Ito po yung programang walang sinasanto, walang silisino.
29:07.1
Thank you for watching!
