SENATOR GARCHALIAN- KASAMA ANG ANG PH JUDICIARY SA KUNTSABA NG CHINESE CRIMINALS?
00:35.9
nung pinanggagalingan ni Gatchalian dito.
00:43.4
Wrong spelling pala yung Gatchalian ko.
00:45.9
Anyway, pasensya na.
00:49.1
Minadali ko kasi mag-type.
00:50.3
Anyway, si Gatchalian yan.
00:54.7
Babaw yung pinanghuhugutan niya para sabihin na
00:59.7
kakunsyabah o may kinalaman ang Philippine judiciary
01:05.4
doon sa mga Chinese criminals.
01:09.3
Pakinggan natin siya mga kabatas natin.
01:12.7
Senator Gatchalian bears the possible influence of Chinese criminals
01:17.2
on the judiciary following a raid of an illegal Philippine off-
01:24.1
ng Philippine judiciary
01:26.1
dahil sa nangyaring raid sa isang Pogo.
01:29.8
...for gaming operator in Pampanga.
01:32.5
Gatchalian says that according to initial information,
01:35.6
the Pogo operator Lucky South 99
01:37.6
already had its license cancelled
01:39.6
but continued its operation nonetheless.
01:45.3
ang may kasalanan doon?
01:47.7
Na kapag na-cancel
01:52.2
nung sinasabi nilang Pogo,
01:54.1
nag-continue pa rin ng operasyon.
01:57.1
Hindi na judiciary, mga kabatas natin,
02:02.1
may kasalanan doon.
02:04.1
Kasi sino ba ang nagbibigay ng lisensya?
02:06.1
Yung business permit, mga kabatas natin,
02:11.1
kung nagbibigay sila ng gaming license,
02:13.1
sila rin kasi ang nang-i-implement dyan.
02:15.1
Kaya nga mga kabatas natin,
02:17.1
pag titignan nyo,
02:20.1
business establishments,
02:27.5
nakapaskil dapat doon
02:29.5
yung mga licenses
02:31.5
ng isang establishmento.
02:33.5
Dapat, nasa batas yan,
02:36.5
na visible yan to the naked eye.
02:40.5
mga kabatas natin,
02:41.5
naked eye and the viewing public,
02:44.5
Sa viewing public,
02:45.5
makikita mo agad,
02:46.5
pagpasok mo dapat makikita mo na agad
02:48.5
yung mga lisensya.
02:51.5
Ang mga establishmentong ito.
02:56.5
Ngayon, kapag hindi nakalabas yan,
03:03.5
Improper display ng mga ganyan.
03:07.5
Tapos, mga kabatas natin,
03:09.5
merong regular na visitation
03:13.5
na ginagawa sa mga business establishments yan
03:16.5
para makita na nagkocomply nga sila
03:19.5
doon sa mga business establishments.
03:20.5
Doon sa requirements ng batas.
03:24.5
Kapag hindi nagkocomply yan,
03:26.5
ano ang magiging parusa?
03:30.5
Tama, maganda yung ginamit ni
03:32.5
words ni Dragazo.
03:34.5
Conspicuous dapat.
03:40.5
mga kabatas natin,
03:41.5
dapat makikita yan.
03:43.5
Pag hindi nakita,
03:44.5
hindi dinisplay na maayos,
03:46.5
may karapat ng parusa.
03:48.5
Kapag walang permit,
03:50.5
May regular inspection yan.
03:53.5
Executive na yon.
03:54.5
Sabi ni Pabstulo at ni Recool,
03:56.5
executive na yon.
03:58.5
Pati yung pag-i-issue ng licenses
04:00.5
kasi mga kabatas natin,
04:01.5
yung pag-core na yan,
04:02.5
that is part of the executive.
04:05.5
Branch of the government.
04:07.5
Sila rin ang nagme-make sure
04:08.5
na lahat na nag-ooperate
04:09.5
dapat may license
04:10.5
kasi sila yung may access.
04:12.5
Kung may license ba yung mga yan talaga
04:16.5
automatic pasara yan.
04:19.5
Automatic pasara yan.
04:20.5
Hindi nga kailangan nang hiring-hiring dyan eh.
04:24.5
mag-produce siya ng permit niya,
04:25.5
wala siyang permit,
04:26.5
automatic sarado yan.
04:27.5
You don't need to go to court.
04:34.5
Nahuli na ito dati.
04:35.5
Kinancela yung kanyang
04:37.5
license siya pero
04:38.5
nagpatuloy pa rin siya
04:45.5
Sagutin natin si Rosenblum.
04:46.5
Rosenblum, pwede po ba
04:47.5
yung attorney yung search warrant nila
04:48.5
galing sa Bulacan
04:49.5
tapos isa-serve sa Pampanga?
04:50.5
Ito ang general rule dyan, no?
04:52.5
Kapag yung paghingi ng search warrant
04:58.5
dapat ito ay gagawin doon sa korte
05:01.5
na may jurisdiction dyan.
05:03.5
So, ibig sabihin yung search warrant
05:05.5
kapag isa-serve sa Pampanga
05:06.5
o sa Pampanga yung
05:08.5
yung ano, yung object
05:10.5
o location ng search.
05:13.5
Doon dapat i-apply yan.
05:14.5
Pero may mga dahilan kasi
05:16.5
kung saan pwede kang mag-apply
05:18.5
doon sa ibang jurisdiction.
05:22.5
Ito ay kung makukompromiso
05:33.5
if you wanna never see me again.
05:38.5
Why? What's that?
05:39.5
Where did that come from?
05:42.5
Zach, where did that come from?
05:43.5
I didn't see the comment.
05:46.5
I didn't see the comments.
05:48.5
Okay, let's wait for the comments.
05:50.5
I'll just continue, okay?
05:53.5
They're saying hi.
05:57.5
You won't see me again.
06:02.5
yun nga yung sinasabi ko.
06:04.5
sino may jurisdiction doon,
06:08.5
yun dapat yung korte
06:09.5
na mag-i-issue ng search warrant.
06:15.5
makukompromiso yun
06:17.5
pag doon siya kumuha.
06:20.5
Compelling reasons.
06:26.5
Ang mga information na kuha ko,
06:29.5
meron siyang seating capacity of
06:34.5
o 1,000 na trabahador.
06:39.5
because apparently,
06:41.5
ng search warrant,
06:45.5
dito sa mga operator.
06:48.5
ang kotob ko dito,
06:49.5
hindi lang enforcement agency,
06:52.5
meron na silang mga tao.
06:58.5
Paano mo nasabi na
06:59.5
judiciary yung nag-tip?
07:06.5
ng search warrant.
07:08.5
Kung ayaw ng judiciary
07:10.5
o kung yung judiciary
07:11.5
ay kakontsaba dyan,
07:13.5
hindi siya mag-i-issue
07:14.5
ng search warrant.
07:17.5
hindi mo ma-zero-in kasi
07:20.5
ng search warrant
07:24.5
In the first place,
07:27.5
ng search warrant.
07:28.5
It's always like that.
07:29.5
Paano ba kasi nangyayari yan
07:30.5
mga kapatid natin?
07:31.5
Ang search warrant
07:33.5
sa pamamagitan ng pag-a-apply
07:37.5
na nagagawa ng search.
07:38.5
Like for example,
07:39.5
here yung mga polis.
07:40.5
Anong kailangan nilang patunayan?
07:41.5
Kailangan nilang patunayan
07:42.5
na may probable cause.
07:44.5
Pag napatunayan nila
07:45.5
sa judge na may probable cause,
07:47.5
mag-i-issue yung judge ng warrant.
07:50.5
ito yung mga polis
07:53.5
ng search warrant.
07:55.5
Ito yung mga polis
07:57.5
ng search warrant.
07:59.5
ito yung mga polis
08:01.5
ng search warrant.
08:04.1
Tapos, itong search warrant na ito
08:05.7
ay i-implement itong mga polis.
08:09.5
So, pag titignan mo dito,
08:10.8
ang trabaho ng judge dyan
08:12.3
ay titignan kung may probable cost to issue
08:15.0
ang search warrant.
08:16.0
Hanggang dun lang yun.
08:18.2
mag-i-issue sila.
08:20.2
Ang implementation,
08:22.6
yung search na rin na gagawin,
08:24.4
ito, mga kabatas natin,
08:31.3
So, pag titignan mo,
08:32.9
mga kabatas natin,
08:34.3
mas malaki ang participation ng mga polis.
08:37.0
So, paano mo masasabi agad-agad
08:39.5
dito na dahil na i-tip yung search
08:44.0
e judisyari na yung kakontsaba?
08:47.4
Tama yung sinabi ni Birks Bala,
08:48.9
it's a sweeping generalization.
08:54.5
It's a sweeping generalization.
08:56.0
You cannot derive that immediately
08:59.5
na dahil may nag-tip
09:02.3
na may nag-tip doon sa search warrant,
09:04.7
e judisyari na agad.
09:06.2
Yung judisyari ang nag-i-issue ng search warrant.
09:08.9
Ang nag-apply, polis pa rin.
09:10.9
Ang nag-implement, polis pa rin.
09:16.1
individuals behind these corporations
09:17.8
know how to illegally deepen their ties.
09:21.3
According to Gatchalian,
09:22.6
law patients know how to illegally deepen their ties.
09:26.4
individuals behind these corporations
09:28.1
know how to illegally deepen their ties.
09:31.3
Marunong nyo silang magkaroon ng koneksyon.
09:37.4
Kasi pwede mo rin naman sabihin talaga
09:39.8
na may koneksyon din sila sa mga senador.
09:44.4
Pero, siyempre, we cannot do that
09:46.6
unless we have actual proof.
09:49.6
Doon sa sinasabi mo rin
09:50.7
na na-penetrate na nila yung judisyari,
09:53.7
siyempre, kailangan din natin sana
09:55.4
ng actual proof tungkol dyan.
10:01.3
According to Gatchalian,
10:02.3
law enforcement authorities have found that
10:06.1
nirevoke yung unang search warrant.
10:09.5
Pero, that's not the point anymore.
10:11.8
The point here is,
10:16.9
nagkaroon ng, ano,
10:21.2
Nung nagkaroon ng hulihan,
10:22.3
iilan na lang kasi nakatakas niyong iba.
10:26.0
Foreign syndicates had been funding POGOs
10:28.2
and working with local criminal groups
10:29.7
and connivance with local politicians.
10:33.2
The senator reveals the information
10:34.7
So, local politicians lang,
10:36.2
walang national politicians.
10:38.2
was disclosed by top officials
10:40.0
of law enforcement and regulatory agencies
10:42.3
during an executive session
10:43.7
as part of the probe into POGOs
10:45.5
by the Senate Committee on Women and Children
10:47.2
and the alleged involvement
10:48.4
of controversial Bamban Mayor Alice Go.
10:52.0
Ito, ito kay Alice Go naman lahat ito eh.
10:55.4
Yung POGO na yan eh.
10:57.3
Dito umiikot sa kanya yan eh.
10:58.8
May labutan ako eh.
11:03.1
ng ating mga intelligence agency
11:05.6
yung kinakatakutan natin
11:07.2
na lumalalim na yung ugat nitong POGO.
11:11.1
Malalim, ibig sabihin,
11:15.1
umaabot na sa mga politiko.
11:18.4
Alam nyo naman kasi, no?
11:20.0
Alam nyo kung bakit malalim
11:24.4
malalim at malawak
11:25.3
ang impluensya ng mga POGO
11:26.5
kasi marami silang pera.
11:31.3
i-solve lang natin yung
11:32.3
graph and corruption
11:33.3
sa pamamagitan ng pag-i-install
11:36.3
ng mga taong tao,
11:39.3
dyan sa gobyerno,
11:41.3
wala naman tayong problema ganyan eh.
11:44.3
Kaya lang naman lumalalim
11:46.3
yung kanilang connection
11:47.3
because they can pay people.
11:52.3
Umaabot na sa mga enforcement agencies.
11:54.3
Yung kanilang galamay,
11:56.3
umaabot na ngayon
11:57.3
kasama na yung mga
11:59.3
lokal na criminal syndicates natin.
12:01.1
At base sa kanila,
12:03.1
nagkakaroon na ngayon
12:04.1
ng interaction nitong dalawa.
12:08.1
Dahil pera ng mga
12:11.1
foreign criminal syndicates,
12:13.1
pumupunta na dito,
12:14.1
pinupondohan nila yung
12:15.1
local criminal syndicates.
12:17.1
Kaya nagsasanib-puwersa na itong
12:19.1
mga masasamang elemento.
12:22.1
Sabi ni Filipina Hilario,
12:24.1
na napanood ko kanina
12:25.1
kay Atty. Claire,
12:26.1
may paliwanag siya kung bakit
12:27.1
maaaring sinadya ang pag-issue
12:29.1
ng defective na service.
12:30.1
defective na search warrant.
12:32.1
Kapag sinadya yan,
12:33.1
pero siyempre alam ko naman si Atty. Claire
12:35.1
hindi niya sasabihin na sinadya yan.
12:37.1
You need proof to show that.
12:39.1
Tapos kaya nga sinasabi niyang maaari.
12:45.1
kapag nag-issue ka ng defective na warrant
12:47.1
o na search warrant,
12:49.1
pwedeng makasuhan yung judge.
12:52.1
Kung siya yung may kasalanan,
12:55.1
Siyempre kasi siya yung nag-issue ng warrant.
12:57.1
Kung defective yung in-issue niya ng warrant,
12:58.1
pwede siya makasuhan.
13:00.1
That's the repercussion of it.
13:02.1
Pwede siyang matanggal bilang isang judge.
13:05.1
Pwede pa matanggal bilang isang abogado.
13:22.1
Okay, ito sa executive session naman
13:24.1
mga kabatas natin.
13:25.1
Paano kapag doon sa executive session na yan
13:28.1
eh merong nilabas
13:32.1
o kaya merong umalingasaw na krimen?
13:37.1
Pwede bang i-persecute yun?
13:39.1
Ah sorry, prosecute pala.
13:42.1
Pwede bang i-prosecute yun?
13:48.1
Hindi kasi masishield
13:51.1
ng isang executive session
13:54.1
ang kahit anumang krimen
13:56.1
na maaaring ginawa.
13:58.1
So pwede pa rin na mag-file ng kaso.
14:01.1
Ang gusto ko mangyari sana dito
14:03.1
magkaroon na ng kaso na ipa-file.
14:05.1
Kasi parang humahaba na lang ng humahaba
14:09.1
at lumalalim ng lumalalim daw
14:11.1
kaya lang parang walang pinapatunguhan.
14:15.1
Several senators have been urging
14:17.1
President Bongbong Marcos
14:19.1
to completely ban POGOs in the country,
14:21.1
pointing out that
14:22.1
Sabi ni Pabstula,
14:23.1
hypothetical yung ka-eternity.
14:28.1
Hypothetical yung statement ni Atty. Clare.
14:30.1
Of course, parang ako din si Atty. Clare
14:32.1
ang ginagawa niya rin.
14:33.1
We are making these statements
14:38.1
for academic discussions.
14:48.1
Maraming salamat mga kabatas natin
14:50.1
at siyempre tulog lang yung sinasabi,
14:51.1
matulog po tayo ng mahimbing.
14:53.1
Dahil alam natin na yung natutulog ng mahimbing,
14:55.1
siya yung laging panalo.
