PART 2: HIMALA NG BICAMERAL COMMITTEE SA BUDGET NG PILIPINAS AYON KAY IMEE MARCOS
00:27.3
natin at Welcome sa isan namang Live
00:30.7
natin Okay ba ung ating audio huhulog sa
00:34.7
patibong Hwag mong tanggapin ang lason
00:38.2
agag nahulog ka sa pitad nila kahit
00:41.4
magpumiglas pa wala kang kawala kalung
00:45.2
ang kulungan kun wary
00:48.8
tinutulungan sinisingil sa bait-baitan
00:54.3
iiwan Okay Alam niyo mga kaps natin no
00:57.3
ang ang ah ginagawa nung Congress ngayon
01:01.0
okay ung Congress ginagawa nila ngayon
01:03.9
ilusot mo na gawin mo na yan Alam mo ung
01:11.4
parang parang bawal na
01:15.1
ginagawa tapos Hayaan mo na lang pag
01:17.7
nahuli Tayo magpalusot na lang tayo
01:20.0
magpalusot na lang tayo mas madali yun
01:22.4
tapos papr prescon tayo araw-araw tapos
01:25.3
sabihin natin ayuda is justice Hayaan mo
01:28.2
na Sige lang tuloy mo mo lang yan basta
01:36.2
tayo na hindi ano pala akap is justice
01:49.0
justice Okay let's go mga natin tul na
01:53.2
natin yung privilege spech Ano magagawa
01:55.6
natin ayuda is justice
02:04.5
ha sabi ni dick ota latest news may
02:07.7
malaking utang daw ang PH health na di
02:10.0
pa bayad at tingog party list naglabas
02:12.7
ng public statement na aatras na sila sa
02:14.8
paghawak ng national budget coincidence
02:17.8
after I miss speech Ipapakita ko nga sa
02:20.6
inyo yung tingog mamaya yung tingog
02:23.3
sinung siya na yung bagong DSWD at PH
02:25.8
health come on oh itong tingog na
02:33.3
' masarap pagtingog in Ano ba ibig
02:37.5
sabihin ng tingog Ano baang ibig sabihin
02:40.3
Ano baang ibig sabihin ng tingog m
02:44.8
Ah ito mga natin let's do this Let's do
02:49.2
this was conducted Did We bother to
02:52.0
ascertain how many senators were
02:53.6
Actually present On The Floor at the
02:55.0
time are even live streamed nationally
02:57.9
nonetheless naiwan kanina na mga kabs
03:00.4
natin na pinag-uusapan natin yung
03:02.2
sinisikreto nila yung mga nangyari dito
03:05.3
tapos sabi ni Amy Marcos inano daw nila
03:08.8
i-invoke na daw nila yung data privacy
03:11.0
kaya hindi daw pwedeng ibigay sa kanya
03:13.0
yung video kung saan nung nung video
03:16.2
nung gumawa sila ng himala doon sa by
03:18.2
Cameral committee Okay Hindi daw pwede
03:21.9
kasi daw data privacy isipin mo data
03:25.0
privacy sa mga tao na pinapasahod mo at
03:29.8
at para sa mga tao na gagawin o
03:34.7
gagastusin yung iyong pera oh ' ba ang
03:41.9
o boses ang ibig sabihin ng tingog
03:46.7
Ah kaya pala maingay sila no araw-araw
03:53.4
Conference tingog to
03:57.0
timbog will quick at tingog Ah okay
04:01.4
sorry tingog pala daw
04:06.9
tingog tingog ni Martin
04:10.1
Romualdez let's go that's the transcript
04:12.5
reveals that the Vi bo voting was
04:14.0
conducted Did We bother to ascertain how
04:16.4
many senators were Actually present On
04:18.0
The Floor at the time I certainly was no
04:20.2
longer there and so many other senators
04:22.3
had determined to depart would it have
04:26.0
ah surip tissues patago
04:34.0
ginawa pag patago yung
04:39.3
ginagawa pagdududahan ka talaga lalo na
04:44.3
kapag yung patagong ginagawa mo
05:00.2
di ba doon pa lang malalaman mo na na
05:05.9
ah to check if as a parent on so
05:09.9
many sabi ni Goliath
05:13.2
online tingog taking ill gotten National
05:16.7
funds Generating opulent gains Very good
05:22.7
that Ah tama tama rin sabi ni Tito w
05:26.8
gaming boses naging boses So naging boss
05:30.6
natin sila no naging boss natin kasi si
05:32.4
Martin romald tsaka yyung buong pamilya
05:34.2
niya e let's go other online videos
05:37.2
there were a Mere 13 members present as
05:40.0
already pointed out some of the members
05:41.4
of the Senate only signed the signature
05:43.4
page after years as the appropriations
05:45.8
vice Chairman for the opposition in the
05:47.4
house I know that it is custom and
05:49.5
tradition as well in the Senate to sign
05:51.4
each and every Page and since
05:55.7
some Alam niyo kasi mga kabatas natin no
05:58.9
kung ano ang dahilan kung bakit ah
06:02.1
especially with with Uh very delicate
06:05.2
contracts like a Deed of Sale ganyan no
06:07.7
you sign each and every page kasi nga to
06:13.1
make sure na binasa mo yyung bawat
06:15.7
pahina Ayon So sinasabi niya na
06:18.9
customarily yung mga tao pag pumipirma
06:22.0
doon each and every page ibig sabihin
06:25.1
sinasabi nila na Nabasa ko yan pero
06:28.3
ngayon mga kats natin ung pinakadulo
06:30.4
lang o yung signature page lang ang
06:32.0
pinirmahan nila ibig sabihin
06:35.2
minadali simply Okay go of the senators
06:38.7
having Never Seen the bik cam report
06:40.1
Until that instant refused to sign all
06:42.8
the pages in the Senate copy of the bik
06:44.6
cam report would it not have been
06:46.8
prudent to determine why did they refuse
06:49.5
before Proceeding to ratify it nair ah
06:53.4
pakialam nila eh gusto nila may pasayan
06:56.8
eh kasi nandiyan yung akap nila eh
07:00.2
ba Why would they even ask you why you
07:03.6
refuse to sign Why would they
07:08.1
care center Why would they
07:11.5
care nga ba ito o isa na namang himala
07:14.8
ang buo kumpleto kada pahin ng pagpirma
07:18.0
ng mga senador natin more disturbing is
07:20.4
the fact that the b report was ratified
07:22.1
even though at the time there was no
07:24.0
final version of the 2025 gab report is
07:27.0
it not the bam report that Was supposed
07:28.8
to embody all the the changes that the
07:30.1
bill had undergone during the bam
07:31.6
conference how can the bc committee
07:33.6
release a b report for the 2025 gab when
07:36.2
the actual 2025 gab was still being
07:46.3
budget Alam niyo mga Katas
07:49.8
natin nanghihina ako sa mga naririnig ko
07:58.4
diyan pina-finalize pa lang ung
08:01.5
gap tapos napirmahan na yun general
08:07.8
act sunod linuluto pa at walang patid
08:11.4
ata itong kababalaghan even as I speak
08:14.2
the final version of the 2025 general
08:16.4
appropriations bill is yet to be printed
08:19.2
as late as yesterday the 177th of
08:21.0
December those in charge of the budget
08:23.3
the real bam are o wala pa yung gab pero
08:26.3
meron na yung act okay
08:30.0
trying to massage the budget masahe pa
08:33.9
po allocating and adjusting among
08:35.6
themselves and their associates the
08:37.0
infrastructure and other projects so
08:38.7
that those who are in their good graces
08:40.4
get a piece of the proverbial pie some
08:42.6
may argue that What will be contained in
08:44.2
the gab is reflected in the bam report
08:45.9
and that therefore It's Not necessary
08:47.1
for the gap to be finalized before the
08:49.0
bam report is released allow me to show
08:51.4
you what the 2025 bc report Actually
08:54.8
looks like at least in General terms
08:57.6
Tingan natin tigan natin mga k natin
09:01.8
oh kasi ito mga kabatas natin meron na
09:04.6
silang ah bcome report sa House Bill
09:10.0
10800 Ito yung sinasabi niya Okay may
09:13.9
House Bill na mga kabatas natin
09:19.4
pero wala pa yung gap
09:22.5
o napag-usapan na pero hindi pa final
09:25.5
yung budget m as an example the DP w
09:30.4
budget has now bloated to a
09:33.4
1.113 trillion the bam report shows that
09:37.3
350 million 483 was added while 61.8 34
09:43.2
was deducted resulting in a net increase
09:45.2
of 28.6 from the bam bill in the summary
09:49.1
report isipin niyo yun hindi naman nila
09:51.2
pwedeng gawin yan talaga eh yung
09:52.9
mag-increase mga kabatas natin because
09:55.6
you will never have a basis in
09:57.9
Increasing the Bud
10:02.0
of this executive department Anong basis
10:06.9
daldalan So ngayon yung daldalan niyo
10:10.5
doon sa doon sa yung daldalan niyo doon
10:16.1
Cameral committee yun yung basis niyo
10:20.7
para Magdagdag laway ano may bayad yung
10:27.3
laway may Bad yung
10:32.4
la baw ko ba there is a m single line as
10:37.6
an explanation for this massive increase
10:40.2
simply stating various infrastructure
10:43.1
projects this runs counter to our rules
10:47.8
natin generic shit ano yung nakalagay
10:51.9
doon Ano ang dahilan nila kung bakit
10:53.8
sila naglagay ng pondo dinagdagan oe
10:58.2
yan structure projects this generic shit
11:02.5
runs counter to our rules you and I know
11:04.6
that under rule 12 section 35 of the
11:06.6
rules of the Senate committee report
11:07.9
must contain a detailed and sufficiently
11:10.1
explicit statement of the changes or
11:11.6
amendments to the subject measure the
11:13.2
same section also provides there must be
11:14.8
a comparative presentation of the
11:16.5
conflicting house and Senate provisions
11:18.4
and a reconciled version thereof along
11:20.2
with explanatory statement of the
11:25.0
luto wala namang paliwanag akat agad
11:36.5
m Wala pal paliwanag kapag instead of
11:40.7
that detailed explanation and
11:42.2
comparative presentation demanded by our
11:44.5
rules We only got various infrastructure
11:47.7
projects vips pala vips meaning very
11:53.0
important persons
12:00.9
word maganda yung ano niya doon acronym
12:04.2
play niya yun kasi various
12:09.2
projects yung acronym na ion VIP So
12:14.9
ring very important persons so yun yung
12:18.1
sinasabi niya I mean ito yung sinasabi
12:20.1
niya yung rule 12 section 35 in the
12:23.9
event that the Senate does not agree
12:25.4
with the house of representatives on the
12:27.2
provision of any bill or joint
12:29.2
resolution the differences shall be
12:30.6
settled by a conference committee of
12:32.6
both houses which shall meet within 10
12:34.5
days after their composition dito wala n
12:39.3
e pinasa na lang agad Sino kaya sila
12:43.3
gaya ng sambit ko hinihimay pa ang
12:46.2
himala pero para sa ilang mga
12:49.2
vips real talk and anyone in this
12:51.6
chamber this August ch yan nakita niyo
12:54.6
yung pinakita niya doon ito sa baba
12:60.0
nakita niyo yanan sa
13:04.6
diyan 21 item number 21 Department of
13:08.2
Public Works and Highways sabi niya
13:11.4
nagkaroon ng variant budget increase ang
13:15.7
linagay lang various infrastructure
13:23.2
galing pwede rin very important Pigs
13:27.3
anan very incompetent part list
13:34.0
yan ascertain What are these
13:36.5
infrastructure projects by just looking
13:38.5
at the bam report can any of us
13:41.1
determine What is included and
13:43.7
comprising the additional 350 additional
13:46.7
funding to DPWH as ' ba Nobody can
13:50.0
ascertain that wala namang makakaintindi
13:52.5
niyan various infrastructure projects
13:55.4
Wala ka man lang paliwanag tapos approve
13:58.5
agad oh ' ba lokohan tayo well as the
14:02.8
projects and programs def funded as part
14:06.2
6.84 reduction I plowed through that
14:09.9
bike sabi ni Stay at home nanay ay hindi
14:13.3
hindi hindi si Undercover ang p
14:15.2
Nagtataka ako hindi umangal si bbm
14:17.3
umangal no Siya ' ba dinefend niya pa
14:22.1
bicam Wala hindi mo naintindihan masyado
14:24.7
ang nazero yung pH health okay
14:29.6
Anyway h Al if ever napirmaan ni bbm ung
14:34.2
bicam na na hindi siya nagbitaw may mga
14:37.8
nilabag ba si pbm na pwedeng reson na
14:40.0
impeach siya mag-fall under impeachable
14:41.9
offense well meron naman tayong generic
14:46.6
na ano doon Meron tayong generic na na
14:54.0
umbrella na ground doon which is
14:56.8
culpable violation of the constitution
14:59.6
okay ngayon if blatantly you see that
15:04.8
such bill Okay is in violation culpa of
15:11.0
the constitution and
15:14.0
still you signed it you ratified it baak
15:21.1
pwed report Which I did not sign hoping
15:24.0
all ods there was a better explanation
15:26.5
somewhere There is not even aint
15:30.4
What ches about And why they came about
15:33.3
the explanation therefore of the
15:36.4
2865 billion increase in DPWH is once
15:45.1
2008 200 billion almost 300
15:51.6
billion siningit lang ng
15:55.2
ganyan Wala man lang paliwanag
15:59.4
infrastructure projects lang ang saya
16:04.7
naman ngayon pag ganyan ka si sin
16:07.2
siningit mo various infrastructure
16:08.7
projects ' ba taas May pondo ka parang
16:12.6
ganyan na it's it's it's it's at your
16:17.4
disposal kasi nakalagay do various
16:19.8
infrastructure projects eh so ang Ang
16:24.6
lawak Ang lawak ng ng Ah ng ang naibigay
16:30.5
Ang lawak ng Naibigay na
16:36.2
pondo desisyon doun sa taong nagagamit
16:39.8
niyan kung ano yung gagawin
16:42.1
niya kasi ' ba mga kabs natin s gak ito
16:45.4
nailagay Dito dapat ilagay dito yan Ito
16:47.9
yung pondo para sa ganyan pondo para sa
16:50.2
ganyan taos p hindi mo ginamit yung
16:52.2
pondo para sa ganon pwede kaang
16:54.2
makasuhan ng technical malversation di
16:56.6
ba o dito wala generic shit lang eh pag
16:60.0
infrastructure yan patayo ka ng flag
17:01.8
poll ta's 20 million Okay na
17:05.3
infrastructure project naman yan eh it
17:07.6
fits the description because it's a
17:09.3
generic shit ' ba projects Ang
17:13.0
mahiwagang Vi sabi ni peg LQ akala natin
17:17.1
sa langit nanggagaling Ang himala pero
17:18.8
sa Congress at Senate din
17:21.6
pala I'm planning to make a very long
17:25.1
live stream Uh well very consistent Live
17:27.6
stream about this okay
17:29.8
so we need the people to know what is
17:35.1
happening ang hinala pa nga very
17:38.4
important persons very important party
17:41.6
list kaya when we were
17:45.8
Wow may shade Don
17:52.0
tingog very important party
17:56.5
list tingog ba yung kanyang
18:04.6
pinaparinggan sa kanya pala galing yun
18:08.4
no let's go ask to sign the b report did
18:11.6
Anyone Of Us have any idea isipin mo
18:13.4
party list ang kumontrol sa budget ng
18:29.3
that the tingog party list of
18:34.6
R is the one that is controlling the
18:37.6
budget kayangkaya nilang maglagay ng
18:43.3
senator specific projects being funded
18:46.4
if our job is to decide which programs
18:48.2
or projects are funded then we are
18:49.9
reming fulfilling our obligations by
18:51.6
approving b report exp
18:57.7
DP miserable words habang O ngayon mga
19:00.9
kabatas natin no ito Ito yung VIP na yan
19:04.2
very important party list ipapakita ko
19:07.6
sa inyo kung bakit kailangan nila ng
19:09.1
malaking budget After this Live stream
19:11.0
Okay billion increase in DPWH with just
19:14.2
three miserable words habang masusing
19:17.2
sinusuri ng ating mga kababayan ang
19:18.8
bawat detalye ng kanilang resibo sa
19:20.4
grocery ang bill sa kuryente para at
19:22.7
yakin tama ang bawat sentimo kanilang
19:24.8
binabayaran tayo naman dito sa senado ay
19:27.2
tila kuntento ng pumayag sa 288 bilyong
19:31.1
dagdag Gamit lang ang tatlong
19:32.9
matalinhagang salita VIP various
19:36.4
infrastructure projects sa totoo ' ba
19:39.4
tama yung sinabi ni Amy Marcos doon eh
19:42.3
Kapag ikaw budget ka ng budget ' ba
19:47.2
Ultimo piso titignan mo kung saan
19:52.3
maggo-grow ' ba tinitipid mo yung anak
19:55.6
mo kapag hihingi ng pera SAO sasabihin
20:00.4
Para saan yan para sa project ma Ah
20:04.6
ganon ba Magkano ba yung project na yan
20:07.8
5,000 Bakit 5,000 Bakit ganyan kamahal
20:10.4
di ba idedetalye pa nung bata kasi ma
20:15.6
ito eh Bibili kami ng illustration board
20:18.4
bibili kami ng poster color bibili kami
20:20.6
ng ganito bibili kami ng ganito bibili
20:22.4
kami ng ganito bibili kami ng ganito ah
20:24.6
Sandali 2,000 lang yan Ah okay Ma 2,000
20:29.9
di ba isipin niyo thousands lang yung
20:32.9
usapan doon ito billions ang saklap Ang
20:37.9
saklap mga kabatas natin isipin mo ganun
20:40.4
yun eh yung gagawin mo parang pero anak
20:43.6
mo pa yun ha Parang sabi niya Oh ma
20:45.6
pingin ng pera magkano 5,000 Para saan
20:48.0
project Okay sige bigay kaagad 5,000
20:50.4
Pero in realidad hindi ganon eh ang
20:53.0
realidad talaga tatangungin mo kung saan
20:54.5
niya gagastusin Eh paano kung gagastusin
20:57.0
niya sa ano bubon
20:59.8
di ba Tapos hingi ka pa ng resibo
21:02.3
pagkatapos di ba o ito balik mo yung
21:12.0
well pera kasi nung nanay yun ito
21:14.9
technically pera din natin to eh taos
21:18.0
isipin mo Penge ng ano 300 billion Para
21:22.6
saan various infrastructure projects
21:25.2
Okay ito 3 billion 300 billion
21:31.7
ba sabi ni Erwin brain child niya daw
21:35.8
akap the more reason na hindi niyo siya
21:40.1
iboboto isipin mo
21:46.0
ba Parang parang kung tayo sa sa
21:50.4
household natin y tayo sa bahay
21:54.6
natin hindi natin hinahayaan na Gan ang
21:59.2
dahil nag-iingat tayo sa pera natin
22:01.2
tapos libo-libo lang yun kung hindi
22:03.0
daan-daan ito bilyon bilyon nakakalulang
22:06.6
pera ito tapos Tahimik lang
22:14.4
mahirap too lang ginagawa pa ba natin
22:17.6
ang ating trabaho worse the committee
22:19.9
allotted a smaller budget to Education
22:22.9
DPWH contrary to the clear command of
22:25.4
article 14 section 5 paragraph 5 of the
22:27.7
constitution which requires that state
22:29.9
at all times assign the highest budget
22:32.1
sabi ni Harley gavana Bakit tahimik baka
22:36.2
hindi nila maintindihan kung ano yung
22:37.9
nangyayari let's give them the benefit
22:45.4
yun priority to Education far from
22:48.4
addressing the learning crisis and the
22:50.0
decreasing digital divide the bc cut 11
22:52.5
billion from the budget of dep ed
22:53.9
including 10 billion from the proposed
22:56.0
ito napaka sobrang ano maanomalya ito eh
23:00.8
isipin mo tatanggalan mo ng budget sa by
23:03.0
camera yun TS sasabihin mo Hindi niya
23:04.6
kasi naipaliwanag yung computerization
23:06.8
samantalang pumasa na
23:08.7
yun sa lower house tsaka sa upper
23:11.8
house ration program sinabi ng Pangulo
23:15.2
nung Lunes sa isang interview k na
23:17.3
ibabalik niya ang budget para sa
23:19.4
computerization pero base sa bc report
23:22.6
ang suma total para sa edukasyon ay 925
23:26.1
billion lamang at ito na ang kinukumpuni
23:29.1
ng dep ed ng suks ng CHED mm tapos
23:32.6
trilyon doun sa kabila at ng TESDA 12
23:36.6
billion pa sa iba't ibang Mga
23:37.9
educational institutions in contrast to
23:40.9
that budget of 925 DPWH has a budget of
23:45.9
1.113 trillion which is 180 m ' ba sabi
23:50.2
ko sa inyo sinungaling yyun si tingog eh
23:52.9
tingog sinungaling yung mga nag-presscon
23:55.8
sa inyo e na pinagsama-sama nila lahat
23:59.4
Tignan niyo yung math ni ano
24:04.0
o has a budget of
24:06.4
1.113 trillion which is 188 billion more
24:10.7
than the entire budget allocation m
24:13.2
sinungaling iun Eh sabi niya pag pinag
24:16.3
toal total mo lahat pero sabi ko nga
24:17.9
Hwag mong pagt talin ' ba pero pag pinag
24:20.7
toal total mo lahat 925 billion
24:25.0
lang sa education sector as a whole
24:32.4
Ah si kon hon yun o si kon hon nga yun
24:35.8
Hindi pero pati naman sila e pati si
24:37.6
tingog Di ba sinabi rin yun '
24:40.2
ba sinuportahan suportahan naman nila
24:43.0
lahat yun eh nagsalita Salita naman ah
24:46.0
Dadagdagan ko yan Dadagdagan ko yan di
24:50.6
Oh ginagawa nilang Bobo ang mga Pinoy
24:55.8
Simpleng Simpleng computation pa nga
24:58.5
sinungaling talaga Ong mga congressman
25:00.0
na to eh no oh 925 billion lang sa
25:03.6
education sector DPWH 1.1
25:06.9
trillion It's really
25:10.0
unconstitutional no matter how You Look
25:12.1
at it It's really
25:13.6
unconstitutional Oh my
25:16.3
goodness taas magsisinungaling po yung
25:19.0
mga congressman nio sa inyo na hindi pag
25:20.9
kinompute mo tinotal mo lahat yan mas
25:23.0
mataas pa rin sa education sector oh
25:25.4
kinompute nga tinotal
25:32.5
malayo yung dpw trilyon yan mga kabat
25:37.1
natin ibig sabihin billions pa rin yung
25:41.8
niya above and over the education sector
25:50.5
tayo for Education I not exp further
25:58.5
because I want I want to go back Okay I
26:04.6
back doon sa mga congressmen na
26:08.6
nagkaroon ng damage tungkol diyan at
26:10.8
i-highlight natin yung kanilang mga kas
26:14.2
kasinungalingan yan yung gagawin natin
26:16.8
sa susunod okay yung budget sa education
26:21.1
tapos titignan natin kung ano yung
26:24.6
pwedeng remedy ' ba Okay
26:31.3
m mataas kasi daw yung 900 versus 1.1
26:35.5
yun lang di katiwa-tiwala yang si kon
26:39.9
Well doun sa ginawa niyang ion Obvious '
26:42.5
ba obvious Oh punta tayo sa kabila mga
26:45.9
kabatas natin ipapakita ko sa inyo kung
26:48.0
bakit kailangan ng tingog ng budget Okay
26:52.3
yan Maraming salamat mga k batos natin
26:54.3
at Syempre tulad na lagi kong sinasabi
26:56.0
matulog po tayo ng miming dahil alam na
26:58.2
natin na natutulog na miming siya ung
27:00.5
laging panalo paam po pansamantala
